Issue
170
8th April 04
BIN THE COUNCIL TAX
The Scottish Socialist
Party's campaign to scrap the Council Tax is gathering pace as the national
demonstration, to be held in
Replacing the Council Tax with a local income tax is a swift and just way
to set about redressing the yawning divide between rich and poor in
It won't make millionaires of the nursery nurses and firefighters, nor
paupers of the merchant bankers and entrepreneurs.
But it will make life an awful lot easier for an awful lot of people. Nearly
80 per cent of us, in fact.
Under the SSP's alternative, the Scottish Service Tax, those on £10,000
or less will be automatically exempt.
No means-testing, no 35-page forms - automatic exemption.
For pensioners, four in ten of whom don't claim Council Tax rebate because
it is too complicated and because they find it demeaning, this will be a godsend
and will enable them to live in dignity.
For young families and workers, it means they can afford to eat better food,
heat their homes properly in winter and contribute to the local economy.
Those on high salaries will be expected to pay a sizable chunk of their earnings.
And interestingly, many people from higher income brackets support this idea.
They understand that we are all part of the same society and that quality
public services rely on progressive taxation.
The Axe the Council Tax demo is our chance to make the will of the Scottish
people heard.
We need to be there in our numbers, so we can stand up and be counted.
Demonstrate against the Council Tax
SAT APRIL 24
12noon,
George Sq,
Phone: 0870 752 2505
US
offensive in
Just when you thought
it couldn't possibly, it got worse.
Four American contract
workers, charred and dismembered, dangled from a British-built bridge across
the
Brutal occupation
But these
risings didn't happen in a vacuum.
They're in response
to an increasingly brutal occupation and the creeping knowledge that, whatever
the
The new interim
constitution, designed to steer
It wants a secular
state, permanent military bases, control of the oil industry and a foreign
policy consistent with
page two
A
socialist for
by Roz Paterson
Last week, Felicity
Garvie was elected top of the Scottish Socialist Party list for the European
elections in June.
Though she has
worked in the Scottish Parliament since Tommy Sheridan's election in 1999,
Felicity is very much a grassroots campaigner and was instrumental in establishing
the SSP's presence in
"I really
enjoyed talking to people in what is a predominantly rural community, affected
by all kinds of issues of poverty and social exclusion.
"I'm looking
forward to getting out there again, this time talking to people all across
Scotland and putting the socialist case to them."
Felicity is "passionate"
about the Free School Meals campaign, with which she has been involved since
its kick-off three years ago.
"I just think
it's a fantastic anti-poverty measure."
She is also committed
to nuclear disarmament, inspired by the dedication of Morag Balfour, the
SSP's Peace and Disarmament spokesperson.
"When I went
to Faslane for the first time, I was struck by this blot on the landscape,
this horrific threat to humanity."
Though the European
Parliament often seems little more than a talking shop, bound up in yards
of red tape, Felicity believes the SSP can achieve a great deal in
"An SSP MEP
can help us make links with pensioners, students and public sector workers,
campaigning against war, the persecution of asylum seekers and attacks on
workers' terms and conditions.
"The environment
is also important and we can help ensure that local communities have a say
in conservation matters, rather than having directives imposed on them from
above."
"These are
problems that exist across borders and we can be instrumental in building
a linked campaign from below."
Farming and fisheries
issues are particularly crucial for
"The sea
belongs to everyone and those who work on it should be talking to each other
and taking control, not being dictated to by distant politicians making
deals behind closed doors.
"These are
complex issues and it's the people in the industry who can lead us to solutions."
Likewise, farmers
are facing meltdown in
In solidarity
with the people she seeks to represent, Felicity will live on the average
Scottish workers' wage, donating the rest to the party.
"
She hopes that a whole
score of left candidates will make it to
"We also
need to address why they are forced to come here: wars, famine, free market
policies that ruin economies and drive down wages.
"These are
European problems and we need to tackle them at source, in the heart of
North Lanarkshire Council
has scrapped its swim-only cards, available to pensioners at £14.50 for
three months, in favour of an Access NL card, which affords access to more
leisure goodies than you can shake a stick at, and all for the knock-down
rate of £15.
Er, per month;
a hike of around 300 per cent.
For many elderly
people, particularly those with heart problems or who have recently undergone
heart surgery, swimming is often the only suitable exercise so inducements
like a free induction at the gym are just pointless.
According to the
wilfully impenetrable statement from the council, who've had a number of
inquiries already about this "improved" service provision, it's
all to do with rationalisation and suchlike bollocks.
What it means
really is that, when you're trying to turn a profit from leisure services,
you can't afford to be all soft on old folk who just want to take care of
their health after a lifetime of hard graft.
The best advice
on offer is to pay as you go, at £1 a time, which works out as four and
three quarter swims a month if you're to keep within the old budget of £14.50.
That'll keep youse
fit.
Not.
Democracy
denied in
by Alan Hinnrichs
Dundee City Council
has made it impossible for
They did offer
a start time of 8am, yet no other May Day demo in
They say the police
are unable to patrol the march and a football match in the afternoon.
In reality, the
council is afraid of allowing the striking nursery nurses a voice. They
are even willing to clamp down on freedom of speech, and halt the international
celebration, to prevent it.
page three
Just a fax to say 'you're sacked'
Workers at Ayrshire
Metals, in
The 43-strong workforce went out on strike a fortnight ago, in protest at
a pitiful pay offer and a series of alarmingly poor severance packages,
some of them dished out to workers who'd put in years of service to the
company.
Dennis Abercrombie, convenor of shop stewards, told the Voice:
"The plant is shut but we still don't know where we stand.
"The union is hoping to get negotiations going with the solicitor's
firm that sent the fax.
"Management is refusing to engage with us directly.
"That shows you the kind of management we have."
Workers feared that Ayrshire Metals was being run into the ground, with
a view to selling the land to property developers.
In the last week, lorries have entered the plant, leaving later loaded with
jigs and fixtures, presumably bound for the parent company's headquarters
in Daventry, in the
A sawmill which sits adjacent to the plant recently closed.
"You can
take everything from there, can't you?"
Despite being
told there was to be 30 days' consultation, beginning April 1st, it now
appears that the majority of the workforce will be out by the end of the
month.
"They're
inviting certain personnel to stay on and help dismantle the plant, so that's
two or three weeks' work for one or two people. That's all."
Locals out to beach supermarket plans
The Portobello Campaign
Against The Superstore (CATS) held a demonstration and balloon-decked motorcade
along Portobello High Street last Saturday.
Property developers
Duddingston House Properties have applied to the council to build an enormous
superstore right in the centre of Portobello.
Local residents
are up in arms; there is already a huge superstore in town and another seven
within reach.
The demo had all
ages represented, including Skateboarders Against the Superstore - a group
of young people who would love a skateboard park instead of a superstore.
Locals who oppose
the development would like to see recreational space as well as affordable
housing.
They are worried
about the effect on local independent retailers and the disturbance of the
inevitably increased traffic.
Dickie Alexander,
the Chair of CATS said:
"We were
suspicious of the developers' traffic level figures and commissioned our
own study.
"This showed
that access roads to the site cannot cope with current traffic levels, never
mind levels in 2006 when they would plan to open the store."
Local people were
joined at the demo against the store by the MP for the area, Gavin Strang,
and local councillor, Lawrence Marshall.
The three MSPs
also in attendance were Susan Deacon (Labour), Colin Fox (SSP) and Mark
Ballard (Green Party).
news
Standard cruelty by greedy bosses
Standard Life has
seen its market value more than halve, from £16 billion to £4.5 billion.
But the bosses
who steered the company towards this disaster are not going to be penalised.
Good gracious no.
Chief executive
Iain Lumsden (who was so good, they got rid of him) and his replacement,
Sandy Crombie, got astronomical bonus packages for losing the company
£12 billion between them.
The same courtesy
was not extended to the 880 Scottish workers they say they have to sack
to cover their gargantuan losses.
Standard Life
employees have no union to fight their corner and, on top of the job losses,
are facing the closure of their final salary pension scheme to new members,
leaving many with nothing in place for their retirement.
Lumsden, by
contrast, managed to secure £338,995 annual pension provision before he
got shown the door while Crombie, on £743,000 per annum, probably isn't
too worried about feeding the gas meter during his twilight years.
Workers are
said to be shattered at the news, with many seriously panicking about
their future.
Standard Life's
plans to demutualise and become a private company, to be floated on the
stock exchange, can only compound this feeling.
Mutual companies
are owned by policyholders but private companies can be bought over by
anyone.
Asset-stripping
predators could spell the end of thousands more jobs at Standard Life.
New marriage law is welcome, but won't reach far enough
by Pam Currie, SSP LGBT spokesperson
The new Civil Partnerships
Bill, currently going through the Westminster Parliament, has been widely
welcomed by the gay community.
Same sex couples
will gain long overdue social and legal recognition of their relationships,
with marriage-style ceremonies taking place in local registration offices.
Gays and lesbians
will have the right to visit a partner in hospital, succeed a tenancy
and share a partner's pension - all rights which have been denied us up
until now.
The Bill follows
the EU Sexual Orientation Regulations, which came into effect in December
2003 and outlaw discrimination and harassment against gays, lesbians and
bisexuals, or those 'perceived' to be a particular sexual orientation.
But does the
Bill go far enough to tackle the widespread discrimination, abuse and
harassment faced by LGBT people on a daily basis?
This legislation
is welcome, but it doesn't give the LGBT community complete legal equality.
Nor does it
protect those who often experience the worst homophobic abuse and attacks
- young people in schools, and low-paid, non-unionised jobs - who will
still be the most vulnerable and the least able to use the law in their
defence.
Council refuses to debate stop on asylum evictions
by Roz Paterson
Last Thursday, SSP
councillor Keith Baldassara tabled a motion at the Glasgow City Council
calling for a moratorium on evictions of asylum-seekers whose claims have
failed.
As things stand, if an asylum-seeker's application fails and they aren't
deported instantly - because their "home" country is deemed
too dangerous for them to return to - they are evicted and all state support
is withdrawn.
This was the spur for the recent hunger strike action by three Kurdish
asylum-seekers living in
They were served their eviction notices last October but weren't actually
thrown onto the streets because their action made the issue politically
sensitive.
The city fathers don't want to be seen acting like callous thugs when
there could be a news reporter around, now do they?
Keith had previously called for outright defiance of the Immigration Act,
which requires these evictions, but "received no support at all"
from other councillors, who feared breaking the law.
So Keith called instead for a moratorium.
"The motion called for evictions to be suspended and for a form of
hardship support to be established, possibly via the Scottish Executive."
However, the council's chief solicitor ruled the motion "incompetent",
which meant that, although it made it onto the agenda at the full council
meeting, it was never debated and the Lord Provost denied a vote.
"I found that incredible and I urge people to contact their councillor
and demand to know why that was allowed to happen," says Keith.
"We're talking about people fleeing repression, fleeing for their
lives, yet if their claim fails and they lose their state support, they're
cast to the four winds."
Find your councillor at: www.glasgowcitycouncil.gov.uk
page four
Rebel
ink
Kevin
Williamson
The visionaries V the Big Four
The
SSP's National Conference in
The mood among party members was upbeat and confident.
But it's hardly surprising when you think of how far the party has
come in the last 12 months.
When you compare the optimism of SSP members with the mood among the
membership of the four biggest political parties then you get a sense
of the times we're living through.
You could understand if one or two of the Big Four were in trouble.
Such are the swings and roundabout of politics. But for all four mainstream parties to be in decline? With dwindling membership? And with disillusionment
among the active ranks? This is a genuinely interesting phenomenon.
New Labour, who still have an electoral grip
on Scottish politics, are losing activists like they're some sort
of political Bermuda Triangle.
In his recent book, as well as modestly claiming that he "was
one of the most talented footballers of his generation" (he certainly
knew how to play keepy-uppy with his finances),
Henry McLeish claimed that Scottish New Labour has shrunk to around
2,000 active members; of which 500 are sitting councillors.
The LibDems conference in
It was so small it could have been held in the back room of a pub
(which would have suited their leader).
On things like GM crops, war, student fees, etc, this is a party that
can look Janus-like in two directions at
once.
You would think that having twice the number of policies as the other
parties would enable them to recruit double the number of members.
Not so.
The SNP are losing activists hand over fist too. Many to the SSP.
Mind you, the SNP have got a tough job on their hands since
finding people who support both Scottish independence and a big business-led
agenda is getting harder than finding a happy face at Ibrox.
The Conservative rank-and-file I don't understand. I suspect the Tory
Party acts for them like an exclusive dating agency, specially designed
to keep a tight lid on their genetic pool.
Their conferences should come with an X-certificate as the attendees
could scare wee children.
You never meet these people in real life. They must just come out
from their crypts at conference time.
If members are becoming disillusioned to the point of chucking in
the towel in ALL FOUR of the 'main' political parties then what does
that say? Surely, much more than any vote at any election, this reflects
a growing disillusionment with mainstream politics.
Yet this glaringly obvious conclusion is absent from almost all media
commentators, who continue to hang on to every last word of the mainstream
politicians, acting as their house propagandists, like they're trying
to breathe fresh life into a dying man.
If a swelling mass of people - maybe even the majority now, who knows
- have become disillusioned with mainstream politics, only voting
for the four big parties out of tradition and civic duty, rather than
any enthusiasm for their policies, then you have to wonder how far
this will go before a populist or even a socialist bandwagon will
begin to gather real momentum.
I'm reminded of the night last year before the vote on student top-up
fees took place in Westminster.
It looked a close call. The BBC's Political Editor stated categorically
that Tony Blair could not afford to lose this vote because it was
his second term's 'Flagship Bill'. That was the lever the Labour whips
used to twist arms.
Think about it: Making students pay more for their education was the
most visionary policy the current
This is staggering in its banality. It's no wonder that those of us
in the SSP feel so optimistic about the prospects for a truly radical
vision to win hearts and minds.
page five
behind the lines
In Holyrood
Plot on the landscape
Before the summer recess,
two harmless-seeming bills - the Strategic Environmental Assessment Bill (SEA
Bill) and Third Party Right of Appeal Bill (TPRA Bill) - are likely to be
laid before parliament.
But watch out - they could be watered down to the point of meaninglessness.
Or even worse: work against the very people they should be protecting.
The SEA Bill stems from an EU directive requiring the environmental impact
of any development to be checked out before it's issued - or refused - the
go-ahead.
But rumour has it
that the Bill, once the Scottish Executive have had their way with it, will
only apply to publicly-built developments.
Public money
Which means that a project like the Edinburgh Royal Infirmary would
be exempt because, although it's a public building, it was built using private
money through the Private Finance Initiative.
The same applies for the M74 extension, which will be mostly funded with public
money but has, however, a sneaky wee percentage of PFI involvement. "If
this is the case, the message is clear," says Rosie Kane.
"If you want to build a road, build it using private money."
Private money built
Another snag is that the Bill is unlikely to be retrospective, which means
no-one can take action against the as-yet-unbuilt M74, because it's already
got its planning permission in the bag.
As for the TPRA Bill, it's come about after years of pushing by the environmental
movement.
The planning system in
Whether a development goes ahead is between the developer and the Scottish
Executive - the ordinary person has no automatic right of appeal.
Even if someone proposes building a nuclear reactor outside your front door,
your only recourse is to hire a lawyer to take up a civil action on your behalf.
This bill is very important, but the devil's in the detail.
Too lengthy or expensive
and it will discourage people just as much as the present system.
Consultation
"We also need to find out who is being consulted on these bills,"
says Rosie.
"Community and environmental groups? Or right-wing pro-development organisations
like Scottish Enterprise?
"Every single community group in
"The Scottish Executive claim to be the listening government, so let's
give them plenty to listen to!"
Consultation documents will be lodged in all libraries as soon as the Bill
is tabled.
n For more info, contact: Mary.Spowart2@scottish.parliament.uk
Holyrood's got it taped
by Carolyn Leckie
The Fraser Inquiry has
done a fantastic job... of clogging up our news bulletins and newspapers with
endless speculation about a building site in
Putting things into political context just isn't how you do things in the
Scottish Parliament, apparently!
Don't get me wrong.
Gerrymandering
The Holyrood project was clearly a piece of gerrymandering by the
Labour Party, designed to undermine the whole idea of self-determination by
making it look like one big waste of money from the very start.
The Scottish Parliament is hardly self-determination but it is an expression
of the people's aspiration for it.
Another problem
with the Holyrood building is that it was built with a four party system in
mind. As it turns out, the Scottish Parliament is made up of seven, not counting
individuals and single-issue candidates, which caused an unholy scramble for
the biggest and bestest offices by the main party leaders.
Dignified it was
not. But on the bright side, I like the new building and the accommodation
is far superior to that meted out to most office workers in
On the subject of
the BBC tapes, not only is it highly unlikely they'll reveal anything useful
to the Fraser Inquiry, politicians have no right to demand their hand-over.
Principle
A hugely important principle is at stake and that is the right of
journalists to protect their sources.
It sounds like hot air but if journalists can't keep their promises to the
people who speak to them, whistleblowers will be too afraid to come forward
and spill the beans on corrupt corporations and governmental malpractice.
Without whistleblowers, we'd never have known that Nixon bugged the White
House or Blair bugged the United Nations.
Instead of leaning on the BBC, maybe the inquiry should be turning its sights
on Jack McConnell.
As a former finance
minister, surely it's a bigger issue that he's not giving evidence?
Holyrood is a smokescreen,
designed to throw us off track. Sure, be angry about the unjustifiable expense.
But there are bigger
things to be angry about.
Hughes sorry now?
Beverley Hughes, one of
Tony Blair's most politically repulsive Babes, has resigned.
Not because she suddenly realised that authorising a dawn raid on a Midlands
Mosque, in order to arrest a terrified Afghan family and deport them to a
fearful, uncertain fate, was a morally repugnant act.
Or that blaming the Ay parents for the family's misfortune was vile and callous.
Nope, she left because she was caught "misleading" parliament on
the sticky issue of dodgy visas issued to "business" people using
forged documents.
However, we shouldn't be too hard on her.
Her going gave David Blunkett the "worst personal day" of his political
life, which is surely something to be applauded.
And, in a personally signed letter to Tommy Sheridan regarding the Glasgow
Kurdish hunger strikers, she expressed thanks that the men had called off
their protest, adding that "it must be clear that we will now bow to
this sort of pressure."
Was it a change of heart?
Or a typo?
We think we should
be told.
centre pages
By any means necessary
From mass
non-payment of the Poll Tax to living in a tree house on a proposed motorway
site, thousands of Scots have taken part in direct action protests. It may
take many forms, but at the heart of direct action is the agreement that sometimes
you have to break an unjust law to change it.
So 90 years after
women ended their direct action campaign for the right to vote, the Voice
takes a look at protests that fought the law, from the Suffragettes to hunt
saboteurs.
by Kath Kyle
This year
marks the 90th anniversary of the end of the militant campaign to gain votes
for women when, at the outbreak of the First World War, the jailed suffragettes
were freed.
Dr Norman Watson has attempted to initiate a process in the Scottish Parliament
which could lead to an unconditional pardon for the suffrage supporters who
went to prison in
The suffragettes were a courageous and militant group of women who railed
against social and political rules to demand the right to vote.
The late 19th century saw society throughout
Working class men, women and children worked in the new heavy industries like
mines, factories and mills. Domestic and farm labour was still common but
all were low paid, unskilled jobs.
Conditions for the middle classes were better. Business was a man's world
but women had fought for and gained greater access to education in colleges
and universities.
Middle class women were able support themselves as governesses, nurses or
teachers.
By the end of the 19th century, with a growing economy and new inventions
like the typewriter, it became socially more acceptable for women to work
in offices and commerce.
Along with better wages the demand for the right to vote in local and general
elections began to gain popularity, especially amongst more educated middle
class women.
The men and women who supported these changes, and wanted them brought about
by democratic and lawful means, were known as suffragists.
Suffragists carried forward their campaign with leaflets, posters, petitions
and other peaceful tactics. But by 1903, some women were fed up with just
asking politely for the vote.
Since the first bill for women's suffrage was put to the parliament in 1867,
it was obvious the tactics were not working.
It was then the famous Pankhursts launched the Women's Social and Political
Union (WSPU) in
These women were committed to a much more radical and direct action method
of fighting for their demands.
The Scottish suffragettes played their part. They targeted the establishment
and attacked the property which represented the ruling elite, smashing windows,
cutting telegraph wires and bombing letter boxes and public buildings.
It wasn't just the demand for the vote which was a threat to the power of
the ruling class - the very fact these women would employ such audacious tactics
sent a shiver through the controlling echelons of society.
And they clamped down on the women ferociously. They were followed, spied
on and secretly photographed.
But the suffragettes continued to openly campaign and use direct action to
force the issue of universal suffrage to be taken seriously.
The scale of the attacks on property escalated, with racecourse stands, cricket
pavilions, Farington Hall in
Many public buildings - including
Despite a backlash amongst some people their demands began to get backing
in many parts of society.
Their bravery was admired by other women and more joined the WSPU and became
involved in the campaign.
They were sent to jail and went on hunger strike to protest about the barbaric
conditions they were held in - a political tactic which has been used many
times to great effect through the 20th century.
In response the authorities sanctioned force feeding.
This is a brutal and dangerous torture which the authorities claimed was for
their own good. But it was used to humiliate, undermine and break the spirit
of the women.
It had the opposite effect on the public and many more people rallied to their
cause when it was revealed.
Four of the five Scottish women who were force fed were held in Perth Prison
and here a doctor at the time gives a description that is not for the squeamish:
"...The ladies would have to be restrained, their hands and legs would
be tied or held and the nose and mouth clamped, the tube forced down and then
left until they felt that they had to attempt to swallow this tube...
"To make sure the ladies didn't vomit it up or regurgitate it they tried
to pinch their nose and they also put a gag on. This risks getting fluid into
the lungs giving pneumonia.
"One of the suffragettes, Mrs Moorhead, did in fact suffer from this
very serious, life threatening complication. It seems clear that in Mrs Moorhead's
case they very closely avoided a major national scandal."
On August 4, 1914, war was declared against
Although Emmeline and Christabel Pankhurst threw themselves into the war effort
as fervently as they had thrown themselves into the suffrage struggle, not
all women followed them.
Many got involved in peace organisations and women's organisations and continued
to fight for universal suffrage.
n There is a video available called Ethel Moorhead from the Glasgow Women's Library.
Global protests for local people
by Roz Paterson
The government
may have given it a cautious welcome, doubtless induced by relentless pressure
from the
And this resistance owes much to the sustained, high-profile direct actions
against GM field crop trials across the country.
For three years, people camped at the edge of Roskill Farm, on the Black Isle,
to protest the planting of GM oilseed rape. They were concerned that an untested
technology, deemed as potentially dangerous as war or a nuclear accident by
insurers in 2002, could wreak havoc on the area's ecosystem.
The Munlochy Vigil inspired anti-GM campaigners all over the world, including
Devinder Sharma, a journalist, writer and filmmaker, who now plans to make
a film about human cloning as a means of highlighting the dangers of GM in
his native
When the crops at Roskill began to flower, releasing contaminating spores
into the atmosphere, over 100 people turned up to lay waste to the crop, using
sickles and scythes.
The same thing occurred at
In
Though the government remains curiously enthused about a technology that nobody
wants, farmers are a little cooler. Not only do GM crops provide quite poor
yields in many cases, and pose all kinds of environmental hazards, they are
unsellable.
The public, alerted by the campaigns, ain't buying it - which just goes to
show that, when you combine direct action with mass participation at a lower
level, you really can make a difference.
By contrast perhaps, the anti-M77 campaign didn't achieve its ends. In 1992,
local man Colin McLeod spent ten days up a tree blocking the proposed route,
armed only with some Robert Burns poetry.
Within weeks, the Pollok Free State, a 100-strong community of individual
protestors living in hand-made huts, had established itself. The protest drew
enormous support from the nearby housing schemes that, years on, are being
hit hard by the pollution from the unwanted motorway.
While the campaign didn't stop the M77, it was the making of a whole bunch
of political activists - including Rosie Kane - and set an important precedent
for motorway protests to come.
A peaceful weapon in the fight against nukes
This Easter
weekend, a long tradition of direct action against nuclear weapons continues
with a 'peace walk' and demonstration at Faslane nuclear base.
In 1960, after a debate about whether it could be legitimate to break the
law, CND officially adopted the policy of 'non-violent direct action'.
In February 1961 4,000 protesters sat down outside the Ministry of Defence
in Whitehall. In September, 1,300 were arrested in
Since then, direct action tactics have been inseparable from the peace movement.
The peace camp set up at Greenham Common in 1981 in protest at the arrival
of American Cruise missiles was probably the most high profile example, particularly
because it was women-only.
One of the Greenham women, Ann Pettitt, describes the imagination involved
in actions as bizarre, yet effective, as blockading the route for new sewage
pipes out of the base:
"There were so many different ways, I suppose, that you could sort of
outwit and startle the authorities, rather than this kind of brutish, unintelligent
head on clash between completely unequal forces, in which you would inevitably
be the loser... I mean non-violent protest, as a form of protest, is much
more intelligent isn't it?"
Recent years have seen a resurgence in activity around Faslane nuclear submarine
base, near Helensburgh, where all of the
A peace camp has been set up there since 1982; originally intended as just
a two week protest, the camp has been the base for thousands of direct action
protests in the last 22 years.
Faslane protests have not only tested the government's commitment to nuclear
weapons, but also challenged the way the law is used against peaceful protest.
Hundreds of people at a time have been arrested at mass blockades of the base,
casting doubt on the legitimacy of
Three women jailed in 2000 for disarming a nuclear laboratory on Loch Goil
were acquitted later that year by a
Sadly, a 2001 ruling overturned that decision and campaigners continue to
be fined and jailed for anti-nuclear actions.
n Easter march and rally
Easter Monday
April 12, assemble 1pm opposite Faslane Peace Camp to march around the base
to rally outside the main gates. Buses will leave
n Easter Peace Walk to Faslane
On Good Friday
April 9, people will be setting off from
Find out more on the Scottish CND website at www.banthebomb.org/events/faslane.shtml
We're no payin!
Simon Whittle
interviewed Alan McCombes about direct action and the Poll Tax
I was heavily involved in a mass campaign of direct action and civil disobedience
against the Poll Tax in the late 80s and early 90s.
Along with a few others, I served 180 hours of community service for leading
a mass occupation of a Sheriff's Office in
Across
Our campaign was galvanised by direct action after mass non-payment had taken
root in communities over the length and breadth of
This mass defiance provoked the authorities, who carried out the work of the
government, to declare war on the communities that refused to pay.
The Sheriff Officers who carried out this dirty work, who we dubbed 'rottweilers
in suits', employed methods from subterfuge to naked intimidation, bullying
and public humiliation to break the resistance the non-payers.
From 1989 onwards, when the first poindings arrived unannounced, the Anti-Poll
Tax Federation (APTF) launched a counter offensive.
For non-payers, we offered advice, material and leaflets - educational propaganda
- saying what we should be doing to defeat the Poll Tax.
We mounted a campaign of direct action across
There would be skirmishes, but nobody got hurt as a result of our protests.
The Sheriffs soon turned their attention to softer targets - like single mothers
and pensioners.
This enraged communities and as the word spread and people joined us and became
organised, whole chunks of
By 1990, the APTF went on the offensive. We took the battle to the doorsteps
of the Sheriffs' offices - a guerrilla war had begun.
I got community service for my part in the occupation of the offices of debt
collectors
The APTF mobilised squads of people to chase Sheriffs away. Their nice cars
stood out in the impoverished communities they were harassing.
Inevitably their cars, which were seen as legitimate targets, ended up getting
damaged as a way of driving the Sheriffs out of the schemes.
We followed them out. Eighty people stormed their
We barricaded ourselves in, deleted files, demanded guarantees like cancelling
pensioners' poindings - we took whatever action was needed basically.
Two days later, 200 police stormed the building after dismantling the doors.
There were mass arrests. Most people got one night in the cells.
But myself, Tommy Sheridan, Keith Baldassara and George McNeilage were treated
as the ringleaders of the occupation and we all got community service.
What's important is that we accepted we were in defiance of the law. At times,
laws have to be broken in order to change things for the better.
The law was unjustified. Our targets were legitimate.
The Proclaimers had this song, What Do You Do When Democracy Fails You?
We had the situation where there wasn't a single Tory MP in
Direct action, outright defiance of the law, forced the state to back off.
The defeat of Thatcher and the Poll Tax changed peoples' attitudes towards
authority.
It made people realise that they could challenge the law, that the law isn't
sacrosanct, that people have the power to bring change.
Out-foxing the hunts
Although
the Scottish Parliament have threatened to ban fox hunting, it still goes
on 'under license'. And as long as the fox slaughtering continues, so do the
hunt saboteurs.
One hunt sab talked to the Voice:
You may start out a mild-mannered kitten hugger, but a couple of days with
the hunt sabs and you become a direct action class warrior with anarchist
tendencies. You just can't help it.
For a start, it knocks that woolly, liberal "can't we all just talk about
this nicely?" kinda crap out your system once and for all.
Attempt to engage with upper-class thugs sitting astride monster horses in
a reasonable manner and they'll threaten to give you a good whipping.
There's therefore nothing for it but to tear round the countryside hollering
and blowing horns (to distract the hounds) and spraying citronella and anti-mate
(to throw them off the fox's scent).
In between bouts of physical exertion, you get to talk to like-minded individuals,
not just about how much you'd like to shoot Princess Anne, but about motorways
driven through working-class communities, corporate greed and rich bastard
landlords.
Hunt sabbing is an immediate and highly effective form of direct action and,
for many, proves a valuable introduction to wider political activism.
And you sometimes
see a fox! And they've got such lovely, furry faces!!
page eight
Your Voice
Basque reality
I think
Lloyd Quinan was right to say that the defeat of former fascist youth leader
Anzar and his Popular Party opens up opportunities for peace and political
progress in the Basque country ('Could the prize be peace for Spain's new
Prime Minister?' Voice 168).
The Spanish people
saw through the state's attempt to use the
All those are vital
steps towards a lasting solution in the Basque country. However, looking for
the PSOE to take those steps is akin to asking David Blunkett to combat attacks
on asylum seekers by mounting a campaign against the right wing propaganda
of The Sun and Daily Record.
The reality is that
Blunkett is part of the problem not the solution. The PSOE will side with
the establishment just as they will side with employers over the working class.
Lisa Johnstone,
Aberdeen
Free the
And President George
W Bush has his economic Blockade against
For these reasons,
all socialists should campaign for the
After being sentenced
to many years in jail, on March 10 they presented their appeal to a
Finally, Fernando
wishes to convey his appreciation to all members of the Scottish Socialist
Party.
Lawrence Morton,
Dundee
n Letters of support to:
Fernando Gonz‡lez Llort Ruben Campa #58733-004 Federal Correctional Institution
Using the right
words in separate schools debate
I welcome
the fact that our party is going to instigate a debate on religion in education,
but I hope that when we do, we start from a more informed position than that
of the conference report in last week's Voice (issue 169).
Differentiating
between schools as "both Catholic and state sector schools" repeats
the misguided view that Catholic schools are outwith the state sector and
that non-denominational schools are somehow generic non-religious schools.
I am a former pupil
of four different Catholic schools and my 15 year old son currently attends
a
What we will find
when we speak to parents about this matter over the coming months is that
choice in most of
Words like 'segregation',
which the Voice did not use but is in our manifesto, also give the wrong impression.
Parents and pupils of all religions can choose which school they attend -
it is not forced upon them. Many non-Catholics attend Catholic schools and
many Catholics attend non-denominational schools.
Segregated schools
are what we witnessed in some American states where black children were forced
to attend separate schools and black parents did not have the choice of deciding
to send their kids to a white school.
By using language
like this we do an injustice to the current situation in
I feel that we made
a huge mistake at conference by failing to back the motion from
Jim Monaghan,
Cumnock
off the air
Colin Bell
From Liddell acorns, big jokes grow
Well, it does look as
if this tiny offshoot of Nostradamus Industries got it right again - the Australians
are about to have Helen Liddell dropped on them from the biggest broomstick
Geoff Hoon can hire. Seems such a pity nobody thought to ship her ancestors
out there while Botany Bay was still in business, and saved
On the other hand,
the prospect of Peter Mandelson going to
More powers to the
European Parliament, fewer jobs for the Kinnocks, isn't a bad slogan as we
go into the Euro-elections.
Standard strife
Remind me, wasn't it Standard Life's Scott Bell who kept taking time off from the onerous task of bringing Europe's biggest mutual insurer to its knees in order to lecture his fellow-Scots about the folly of thinking they could run their own whelk-stall?
So Sewel me...
Which, of course, we still
don't do. Remember at all times that the grisly saga of Follyrood is one foisted
on us by Mother Donalda and Westminster, before our own Parliament had even
been elected, and that there has never yet been a judicial inquiry into the
fatuous Dome, which cost more and only lasted a single poorly-attended year.
And if the current
Executive carries on as it has, you might readily assume we still haven't
got a Parliament of any sort - Jack and Jim's Flowerpot Persons who dodge
all serious issues and rely on the
page nine
cultural resistance
Looting and burning
by Matt Preston
Five
years ago, music piracy was dodgy CDs from the Barras or making a tape
for a friend.
The music industry claimed we were killing music, but nobody swallowed
it.
Today however, anyone with a decent internet connection can download almost
any tune they want in minutes.
And they are. Twenty million people download every day in the
The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) claim this has caused
a 12 per cent fall in album sales over the last two years, and that, yes,
we are killing music.
Artists from Brian Wilson to Missy Elliot are lining up to wag their fingers.
Not that the industry is taking it lying down. The RIAA are tracing downloaders
over the net and taking them to court.
In
You may think this is a fair cop. You play with fire - eventually you'll
get a wee bit more than a burned CD.
But some are taking a more militant attitude.
The website Downhill Battle makes the point that, yes, filesharing is
damaging the industry; an exploitative, corrupt, manipulative industry.
And we should keep sticking in the knife.
"Instead of asking 'what's good for major label CEOs and profit forecasts?'"
they say, "we want to ask 'what's good for music, musicians, and
fans?'"
They describe an industry dominated by five major labels (EMI, Sony, BMG,
Warner and Universal) controlling 85 per cent of world music sales.
The majors maintain this monopoly by bribing radio stations to ignore
independent labels and illegally inflating the prices of CDs. The argument
that filesharing harms musicians fails when you learn that most are likely
to see nothing from the £15 you spend on a CD, and at best they'll get
5 to 10 per cent.
Downloading music becomes "a widespread act of civil disobedience...
that could completely transform the music industry".
This is no idealistic excuse for free tunes.
They promote a conscious piracy, targeting the majors but maintaining
support for independent labels and artists; kind of like Fair Trade with
teeth.
Downhill
Documentation of the majors' crimes, discussions of alternative ways to
fund artists, up-to-date news and a good set of links all make sure you
stay well read.
Interviews with artists and independent labels expose the sell-out stooges
defending corporate profits.
Downloadable leaflets and stickers allow you to take the fight to your
high street.
And with the built-in player you can listen to unsigned acts while you
browse. Check it out and take a peek at the future of music: controlled
by musicians and fans, not by the fatcats.
n www.downhillbattle.org also see www.RIAAradar.com
women's voice
Lani Russell
The lights go out on sex...
The idea
that single women can be happy, good, sexy, and not be in any rush to
find a man is pretty radical.
This is why
I loved Sex and the City, which recently ran its final episode after nearly
a decade.
Researchers
say that on average, single women live longer than married women and married
men live longer than single.
So if relationships
are a health hazard for women, why are so many of us in them or intent
on finding one? One answer is that we simply can't afford not to be.
What with the
cost of rent and toothpaste, singledom could be viewed as a luxury.
Another is that
a relationship can offer two things we need in one go: companionship and
sex.
Negative
But
there's another answer too, which is that society has been very negative
about women who try to make it without men.
Single women
(and lesbians) have been portrayed as sad (nuns), bad (witches), ugly
or desperate.
Yes, this was
a show about disgustingly rich women.
Lead character
Carrie is a walking clothes horse (and about as fleshy).
But that doesn't
mean the show didn't speak to ordinary women. It portrayed us placing
a high value on the company of other women.
It defied censorship,
and showed sex from a woman's point of view.
The characters
take their sexual pleasure seriously, and they enjoy talking about it.
Get these four
in a coffee shop and they dissect their sexual experiences with the intensity
of wine tasters (or is that civil engineers?).
With their tongues
firmly in their cheeks, the writers defied all kinds of taboos: masturbation,
anal sex, threesomes, fetishes, 'tantric celibacy'.
The result was
some hilarious storylines - and footage, thanks especially to Samantha,
whose exuberant bedtime gymnastics made for great TV.
The show celebrated
women's sexuality, but it also had some pretty subtle and confronting
things to say about the ways that women relate to men.
Charlotte is
a hopeless romantic who can't accept men as they really are.
For Samantha,
sex is like a sumptuous meal, spoiled only by the slightest whiff of intimacy.
For Miranda,
relationships are over-rated but she's actually very lonely.
What jarred
Sex and the City for me wasn't the opulence, it was the ending. So they
all find partners and live happily ever, what's wrong with that?
Turning
40
They
are rich, after all, and if anybody as a chance of happy relationships
it should be the rich - the greatest enemies of love and sex are poverty
and stress.
Problem is,
there was a clear message by the end that it's all very well for women
to play around into their 30s but as the big 4-0 (and the horror of infertility)
approaches, it's time to get those wedding rings on those fingers (and
stop having so much fun!).
Since when was
turning 40 the end of everything?
But hey, I'm
38 and childless so I would say that!
page eleven
international news
Rwandan blood still stains ten years on
"We
heard a child cry out in the brush. We were furious because we thought
it would bring the death squads. I thought to myself: 'Shut up child.
Shut up or die.'
A policeman
found him covered in blood but not wounded. Later, I looked at the boy.
I hadn't been able to see him before because it was dark. It was my son."
A survivor of the Rwandan genocide
by Emma Miller
April
7 has been designated by the UN as an international day of reflection
on the genocide in
The failure of the international community to intervene in this mass slaughter
still represents a monumental failure of the 'civilised world'.
Further, the Western media's stereotyped and simplistic reporting of
On April 6, 1994, triggered by the shooting down of Rwandan President
Habyarimana's plane, a planned campaign of slaughter was unleashed by
extremist Hutus, against members of the Tutsi ethnic group and moderate
Hutus.
Pressure
Meanwhile, instead of acting to save lives, the UN Security Council
drastically reduced the presence of UN troops.
After the killing started, the UN did propose to dispatch 5,500 troops
to help stop the massacres.
Pressure from the
Within
Many Hutus who resisted, or intervened to save Tutsi lives, were butchered.
While the Christian churches in
The imams called on Muslims to oppose the killing.
The international media played a contributory role. Critical political
and economic factors, such as the interests of the West, were obscured
in media coverage by a tendency to concentrate on ethnic identity as a
cause of war.
The conflict could then be presented as ignited by primitive causes beyond
the influence or understanding of the West, fitting a Hearts of Darkness
portrayal of
Afterwards, a multinational evaluation of the genocide charged that since
the Western media failed to report adequately, this "possibly contributed
to international indifference and inaction, and hence the crime itself".
Failure to report the complicity of prominent members of the international
community (notably France,
There are positive signs of recovery in
There is the work of the local (Gacaca) courts system and the commitment
of many Rwandans to reconciliation. For the first time since
As with most conflict in
Canadian Professor John McMurty explains that IMF policies had a critical
role in destabilising
From 1990, IMF interventions resulted in the collapse of earnings, triggering
steep price increases in food and fuel and rapid increases of malaria
and malnutrition.
In 1992 IMF policies resulted in utility privatisations, and reduced public
investment.
The money disbursed to the Habyarimana government from new loans was used
to purchase weaponry from
The massacre began shortly afterwards.
"All was reported in the corporate media with no connection back
to the IMF prescriptions which had step by step engendered the social
pathology," notes McMurty.
The IMF continues with its failed impoverishing policies in
Although
If the international day of reflection on
Blair's
visit rebrands
by Nick McKerrell
Tony
Blair's visit began
The world's media watched as Blair shook hands with Colonel Muammar Gaddafi.
Once denounced as a supporter of terrorism and bombed by the
The spur for this meeting was Gaddafi's announcement in December last
year that he would renounce a programme of building weapons of mass destruction.
At a similar time
This is despite the legal case against Abdul Basset al-Megrahi, convicted
for the bombing by a Scottish court, being paper thin with a major appeal
in the pipeline.
But the changing relationship, culminating with Blair's visit, have a
clear purpose for both sides.
Gaddafi wants the
This would allow American investment in the oil industry which Gaddafi
and his Prime Minister Shukri Ghanem see as essential for developing the
economy.
Gaddafi has always been a maverick leader, at one time promoting his own
unique vision of socialism.
He labelled
For the
Three per cent of the world's oil reserves are in
European companies want to beat the rush, specifically US companies, and
are moving fast to get their noses in the trough.
On the very
same day as Blair met Gaddafi Shell signed a deal with the Libyan national
oil company.
Blair who has
spent the last two years denouncing 'terrorist' leaders and promoting
'democracy' can now declare Gaddafi to be a 'brave' man.
It really is
all about the oil.
page twelve
voice at work
BACK THE STRIKERS
Support a national deal
for nursery nurses
"The suffragettes
would not be silenced and neither will we."
So
said Barbara Foubister, UNISON
Trade unionists
across
PCS member Gerry
McMahon told the Voice:
"Glasgow North
branch executive has unanimously agreed to a workplace collection in all sites
and we will do all we can to give ongoing support for national settlement.
Low pay
"The
Department of Work and Pensions staff are out on strike on April 13 and 14.
I've no doubt that nursery nurses will be standing with us then.
"Low pay is
a common issue here and it is all too common across the public sector.
"Also, both
unions are predominantly women, 70 per cent of the civil service is
women, and there are common problems in terms of pay increases.
"The nursery
nurses haven't had a pay review in 16 years.
"They implement
a national pre-school curriculum and deserve a national, professional wage."
Last week, the nursery
nurses dressed as suffragettes and took their message to
Barbara Foubister
told us:
"We do wonder,
if the nursery nurse profession had been predominantly staffed by 'guys' -
would they have had to put up with such low pay for so long?
Empty words
"Instead
of all the empty words from 'guys' in the Scottish Executive and CoSLA, we
want some action, some real talks and a real attempt to resolve this national
dispute."
Six weeks without
a wage, especially such a low wage, is a strain for anyone.
A nursery nurse
from
"This is about
the future of our profession. It is about the quality standard of childcare
that we are willing to accept in
"They want
professional caring staff to look after their kids and they understand the
job we do is more than worth a living wage."
SSP councillor Keith
Baldassara put a resolution to Glasgow City Council calling on them to back
the regrading claim and a national deal.
Every single Labour
and LibDem councillor voted against it. Keith told the Voice:
"Glasgow City
Council, as the largest local authority in
The nurses are determined
to fight for a national settlement for a national job.
They have organised
local pickets and demos all over the country and at the picket of Glasgow
City Council, when Keith put his resolution, Caroline McGrory, said:
"We're very
much still up for this fight.
"We're staying
solid - it's definitely a case of 'united we stand'. We've come this far and
there's no way we're going back now. And I think support form the public is
getting stronger - we're starting to get through to them.
"We've had
a bit more publicity in the papers and it's been more positive. I think maybe
that's to do with the politicians taking more of a stand. The Scottish Socialist
Party and the SNP have been saying good stuff in the Parliament - more MSPs
taking our case up can't do any harm!
"The
more people willing to talk about our dispute the better."
From pickets to picnics...
n
The nursery nurses are calling a demo by the seaside. They will be heading
for
n They also have their ongoing series of local demos and pickets. Go along to your local nursery to offer support. Early in the morning is best.
Send messages of support
and, most importantly, donations to: The Nursery Nurses Campaign Fund, c/o
UNISON,