Scottish Socialist Voice
Issue 284
3rd November 2006

back to index


—front page—

CLIMATE CHANGE: COSTING THE EARTH

Climate change may cost us the Earth. But what’s woken up the rich and powerful is that it may cost them $9.6trillion.
Nicholas Stern’s report for the UK government has made more waves and shook up more boardrooms than any apocalyptic visions of mass famine and drowned land masses could ever do. As ever, money is the only language these guys understand.
If Western governments ignore this warning, it will cost them dear - 20 per cent of GDP if all hell breaks loose, and the glaciers melt, the seas rise, water shortages become chronic and food becomes scarce, compared to a mere one per cent if they act now.
In fact, we have the wealth, and the know-how, to offset catastrophe. We just need the political will.
Businesses and their mates in government have always claimed they can’t combat climate change because it’s too expensive. Stern spells it out - it may be steep, but the cost of doing nothing is astronomical.
The UK government says it wants to set an example to the rest of the world.
May we offer a few suggestions on how to set that example.
First up, make the polluter pay. Corporations should be taxed on every tonne of carbon they belch into the atmosphere. That way, they may just find it worth their while using cleaner energy sources.
Annual targets to reduce our fossil fuel emissions by 80 per cent by 2030 must be put in place, and met. We can’t leave it to market forces; we need rigorous and comprehensive legislation.
Next, how about a fully-integrated, publicly-owned public transport network.
Get everyone out their cars and onto buses and trains. Costly? Well, how about ditching the pig-ignorant road-building and airport expansion projects and using that money to offset costs?
Publicly-owned housing should be insulated and double-glazed. No company should be allowed to sell or rent a property unless it has these features in place.
All out-of-town retail developments should be scaled back and planning permission denied from now on. Thus town centres can thrive again and people need no longer be so dependent on cars.
We need massive investment in renewable energies, including wind-farms, perhaps off-shore, and wave power. George Monbiot suggests a hydrogen pipeline network to replace the natural gas network, and wind-farms connected direct to the grid. Where will the money come from? Why, it’s sitting in the budget, earmarked for Trident.
So much must be done, and so urgently, that it’s easy to live in denial, or convince ourselves that there are more important issues. But are there?
Climate change is not an issue, it’s the context in which everything else happens. We can change laws, governments, attitudes - we can change the world. But if we allow climate change to reap its grim harvest, the game’s up, and we can do nothing.

—page two—

MacKinnon Mills workers prepared for the long haul

Workers at the Mackinnon’s Mills Factory in Coatbridge continue fighting for a pay rise in the face of increasingly desperate tactics from management.
The workforce are solidly supporting their claim for a 2.5 per cent pay rise which would hardly make a dent in the £23million profit made by the company last year.
Despite being a long-serving, loyal and skilled workforce, this is not the first time the company has refused a pay rise and has so far failed to negotiate with Community, the union to which the largely female workforce belongs.
In a significant victory last week, the union successfully defeated a court injunction to move the workers from the factory entrance.
They have successfully encouraged customers not to shop at the factory’s retail outlet on strike days. Trade is now down by 20 per cent on those days.
On one occasion, a bus load of pensioners from the Borders went on to Lanark rather than put money into the greedy company’s pocket.
Agnes, one of the strikers, reflected, “the cost of the court action could probably have paid for our pay rise. It just sums them up; that they’d rather go to court than pay us what we’re due.”
Local SSP members and Central Region MSP Carolyn Leckie have visited the picket line and Carolyn has tabled a motion in Parliament to highlight the dispute and demand that management enter meaningful negotiations with the union. She has also written to management directly, calling for them to meet the workers’ demands.
Spirits are high on the picket line, with Mary summing it up: “There’s no way we are going back there with them thinking they can get away with treating us like this any longer. If it takes the long haul so be it but we’re here to win.”
Messages of support to Willie Paterson, Regional Secretary, COMMUNITY, 102 Hamilton Road, Motherwell.

Save the Vale

Local Labour MSP Jackie Baillie “is too busy in a grubby party power battle” to fight for the survival of the Vale of Leven hospital.
That was the charge from West of Scotland Scottish Socialist MSP Frances Curran after news emerged that Ms Baillie had suffered a vote of no confidence from her own party members.
Said Frances:
“This extraordinary move is the latest twist in the story of Labour twisting and double-dealing over Vale of Leven hospital.

Elections
“It is now clear that the future of the hospital is, for Labour, a pawn in the wider battle for power after next year’s elections. It’s more to do with snouts in the trough than services for the sick.
“Last week we were told by the health board that the hospital would close but after I raised it with Health Minister Andy Kerr in the Scottish Parliament, Labour politicians told another story.
“Kerr was leaked private letters from me to the board, and quoted them in Parliament in a desperate bid to put up a smokescreen.
“He is now engaged in a full-scale PR exercise to save the rapidly fading career of his friend Jackie Baillie and both are telling the public that the hospital will not close.”
Frances believes their tactic is to keep the Vale open until the May elections are “safely out the way” before “nodding through” closure if they win power.
“Both of them are guilty of using patients in the Vale of Leven as pawns in the grubby game of political musical chairs in the Labour Party.
“However local people will not be fooled by them and will continue to fight to save the Vale and I can promise them my full support in that fight.”

Blair survives inquiry vote... but only just

by Dick Barbor-Might

Nemesis comes slowly for Tony Blair, but it has not quite caught up with him yet. As we go to press he has survived a critical vote about the Iraq war in the House of Commons, this time by just 25 votes.
David Cameron’s tactical switch to an anti-government position, which annoyed some of his own Tory backbenchers, was not enough to swing the vote against Blair. 
With a few honourable exceptions Labour MPs at Westminster did the dishonourable thing on Tuesday evening and voted to suppress an effective inquiry into the Iraq war. 
The issue, we might remind ourselves, is why and how Blair got us into a war in which hundreds of thousands have died, most of these being Iraqis but also with a steady growing contingent of dead American and British soldiers.
There are ruined lives and in Iraq a ruined country. The reports come pouring out.

Demonstration
Back to Westminster and to the place of the Iraq war in our politics.
On Sunday I found myself in Parliament Square being asked, very courteously, by a policeman if I was aware that I was part of an unauthorised demonstration and that I was in danger of committing an offence under Section 132 of the Serious Organised Crime and Police Act.
This offence, in essence, was to join others so as to maintain a presence in the Square through till Monday. This was so as to read out the names of people, Iraqis and British, who have been killed in the war.
For our masters such gentle acts of remembrance are crimes.
But I am happy to report that they are obviously nervous that this Act is in danger of becoming unenforceable. Because, over the 24 hours, only a very few were detained - and then released without charge, one of them even rejoining the demonstration. 
The cat and mouse games were a sign of a nervous authority, nervous of the publicity induced by arrests and nervous of the people’s contempt.

War on drugs?

Drug taking has reached a new high within the ranks of the British military, and this time, it’s officially endorsed.
MPs learnt last week that the MoD has been stockpiling ‘zombies’ - Modafinil pills which can keep the user awake for days at a time.
The MoD has also been testing Ephedrine, the amphetamine-like substance famously banned by the International Olympic Committee (IOC).
A scientist at Qinetiq, the private firm contracted to carry out the testing, commented: “One is always looking for something that would give military personnel an extra edge.”
Here’s an idea. How about some body armour, decent food and a half-rational foreign policy?
The MoD and Qinetiq seem quite unconcerned that the idea of pumping young soldiers full of dodgy drugs and then shunting them into a war zone is abhorrent to many and extremely dangerous.
For the soldiers, there are the side-effects, from anxiety to erosion of good judgement. And for their victims, it can be much worse.
In April 2002 came a case of two US military pilots mistakenly bombing a Canadian infantry unit in Afghanistan, killing four. It later emerged that the men had felt under pressure to take amphetamines.
On the home front, a new study reveals Scotland’s Methadone programme to be failing, with a success rate of only 3 per cent over three years, compared to 30 per cent for residential detox and rehab.
At £400 a week, the latter is a costly option,, and thus there is an 800 people-long waiting list.
Dr Neil McKeganey, of Glasgow University, and a co-author of the report - Abstinence and Drug Abuse Treatment, written in conjunction with Oxford Brookes University - believes there is insufficient provision for addicts who want to be drug-free.
Too many, he feels, are simply parked on Methadone, which certainly helps users stabilise their lives but is very addictive and can lead to an individual’s drug use spiralling upwards again.
He called for more residential services and an inquiry into why the Methadone programme was achieving such poor results.
“It is going to be necessary to ask some pretty searching questions about the Methadone programme as to who actually is benefiting from it.”

Less Legal Aid, less justice

by Nick McKerrell

This summer saw a major battle between the entire legal profession and the Scottish Executive, over the level of fees paid by Legal Aid.
A settlement was eventually reached in August after the Law Society of Scotland threatened complete non-cooperation over complex law cases with the Executive. 
Battles over legal fees are often portrayed by Hugh Henry and Cathy Jamieson, the New Labour Justice Ministers, as them standing up to fat-cat lawyers. But in truth, they are just another form of funding cut for public services.
In Scotland, Legal Aid  subsidises people who cannot afford legal fees, and relies on private firms taking cases and then applying to the state for the funds. This is quite unique in the world, many other legal systems having public defence lawyers, who are really civil servants, defending poorer people accused of crime.
Since New Labour came to power, Legal Aid has almost completely disappeared for civil law cases, leading to a number of legal firms adopting no win, no fee policies, and enabling firms with no legal basis to act as negotiator for individuals - particularly those harmed in accidents - and then take a huge slice of the damages.
This is arguably less fair than Legal Aid as the client can end up losing most of their damages in fees - this is pretty much the American model of justice.
In criminal cases, rather than examine the actual work carried out, the Scottish Executive want to experiment with paying a flat rate per case.

Miscarriages
Academic research recently leaked to the BBC shows that without properly funded legal services, miscarriages of justice are more likely as legal firms who cannot devote proper time and resources to defending their client will cut corners, ignore evidence and not prepare fully for the court hearing.
This also has its corollary in prosecution - cuts in funding for the Crown Office means preparation for major criminal cases can be weak. 
This was one of the conclusions into the inquiry over the failed prosecution of the Surjit Singh Chhokar murder trial.
Driven again by costs, the Scottish Executive have also experimented with American-style public defenders. There are already small offices established in Edinburgh and Glasgow, and it was announced last week that this was going to be rolled out in other parts of the country. 
This is the norm in large areas of immigration law. However, although you get many dedicated lawyers in this type of work, they are even more in the frontline of cuts in public funding.  
And experience in America shows there is more pressure on public defenders to strike a deal with prosecutors to prevent a case coming to court, which can be unfair to the client.
It is really difficult to have a proper discussion on what a fair legal system would look like in the current neo-liberal climate of capitalist Scotland.
Like so many other debates, it is coloured by New Labour’s desire to have permanently low public expenditure.

—page three—

SSP and RMT: despite disaffiliation, more unites us than divides us

by Richie Venton
SSP national trade union organiser

The national executive of the Rail, Maritime and Transport (RMT) union last week voted to disaffiliate from the Scottish Socialist Party.
This decision is deeply regrettable to all those who fight for genuine political representation of the working class against low pay, privatisation, anti-union laws and wars for oil.
It is an undeniable setback - not just for the SSP, but also for the RMT’s membership, who need a genuine, organised political voice in the face of ruthless railway and shipping bosses, and New Labour’s anti-union government.
It is all the more regrettable given that the policies of the SSP remain unchanged and totally in tune with those of the RMT.
The RMT affiliated to the SSP in the first place because they had the courage to break from New Labour and recognised that the SSP’s policies on privatisation, workplace rights, public ownership and the bloody war in Iraq matched the union’s own aims and aspirations.
They also took that historic decision in acknowledgement of the outstanding solidarity the SSP had shown to RMT members and other trade unionists in struggle over the years. None of that has changed.
Close vote
The decision at the RMT’s national executive arose from a vote to disaffiliate at the union’s Scottish Regional Council. That vote was about as close as it gets; just two delegates voting the other way would have meant continued affiliation to the SSP.
And as SSP national convener Colin Fox commented after the RMT vote: “I also regret the union never offered the party any opportunity to put our case.”
In fact, the case for staying with the SSP is overwhelming, and where individual RMT members have presented it, other members and RMT branches have wanted to stay affiliated.
Where else are they supposed to go? Back to New Labour? That, of course, would be the preferred option of some of those who voted to disaffiliate from the SSP - but certainly not of the vast majority, including a number of principled trade unionists who still vote Labour but argued for the union to remain with the SSP on the grounds that its policies remain the same, and match those of the union.
When Tommy Sheridan, the SWP and some others decided to split off from the SSP, I warned in a letter to trade unionists:
“This is an act of utter disloyalty and irresponsibility to the hundreds of thousands of working class people whose hopes have been raised by the Scottish left uniting into the one party - the SSP. It would be a particularly cruel deceit of those courageous trade unionists who fought for and won affiliation of the RMT to the SSP.
“These workers did not affiliate to Tommy Sheridan - they affiliated to the PARTY whose working class socialist policies and fighting record matches their aims and aspirations. Why should they be dragged off into the wilderness by a split-off from the SSP?”
Their split-off had no political justification, but one of its consequences is the RMT’s decision.
The RMT’s national executive quite explicitly and unanimously voted NOT to affiliate to Solidarity. That reflects the widespread distrust felt by RMT members. But by splitting from the SSP, Solidarity disheartened and confused enough RMT activists to allow the narrow majority on the RMT Regional Council to vote for disaffiliation.
The only victors in this are the enemies of socialism and trade unionism.
This is not the end of the story, however.
The reasons the RMT broke with Labour and affiliated to the SSP in 2004 remain with added force. RMT members face the same attacks from the employers and the war-mongering, privatising, anti-union New Labour.
Picket lines
They will be forced into industrial action in the months and years ahead - and the SSP will continue to stand on their picket lines, organise solidarity with them, and act as the voice of RMT members in the streets, workplaces, councils and parliament.
Disaffiliation does not suddenly mean we will sever all links with the RMT or its members.
As Colin Fox said last week: “All the reasons the RMT gave for affiliating remain entirely valid. We share a mutual loathing of New Labour and all it represents.”
This setback changes nothing in our determination to join with others in breaking the insidious link between New Labour and the unions.
Pouring millions of members’ subs down New Labour’s throat does even less for the affiliated unions now than when the RMT dared to defy New Labour’s diktats two years ago and were subsequently expelled.
And union members are increasingly reaching breaking point in their link with Labour. The fact that the TGWU leadership has taken the unprecedented step of putting a case for continued affiliation to Labour on their website this month is proof of the clamour of discontent from TGWU members.
The working class needs an organised political voice and vehicle for socialism more than ever.
The SSP remains that party, and we will continue to campaign shoulder-to-shoulder with the RMT and other unions on the daily struggles and bigger socialist aims that unite us.

Shop stewards launch network

by Gregor Gall

Some 250 trade union activists from all over Britain gathered in London last Saturday for the RMT-initiated National Shop Stewards’ Conference.
A number of general secretaries of left-led unions addressed the gathering, though ample time was also given over to contributions from the floor from union activists.
An RMT statement was passed, establishing a steering group to set up the Network, primarily by organising a formal delegate conference in spring 2007.
This will attempt to bring together as many of the UK’s 230,000 workplace reps as possible to form the new Network, the purpose of which is to offer trade unionists help and support in their campaigns and disputes.
This initiative is important as it will try to link up trade unionists from different organisations at the grassroots level, in a way that the present structures of the union movement do not.
The TUC Annual Congress is dominated by full-time union officials and national executive members and discusses an agenda that is far removed from immediate workplace concerns.
The thinking behind this RMT initiative has been that for a new party of organised labour to emerge, the union movement must be bigger, stronger and more assertive.
The National Shop Stewards’ Network is an important step.
While the spirit of many attendees was to invoke the heritage of shop stewards’ movements of the 1910s and 1960s, the conference settled for the more modest and realistic aim of founding a support network for ordinary trade unionists in struggle.

Bloggers of the world unite

by Roz Paterson

At a time when the free press has never been more under threat - in Russia, where investigative journalist and Putin arch-critic Anna Politkovskaya was recently gunned down by a suspected contract killer, in the US, UK and Australia, where media ownership is dwindling further and further into the hands of fewer and fewer people, in China, Zimbabwe, Iraq, wherever you care to look - the internet has become a refuge for free-thinkers everywhere.
But even on the world wide web, free speech is coming under attack as bloggers - that is, online diarists and journalists - face threats and imprisonment for the political content of their blogspots.
A case in point is that of Iranian blogger Kianoosh Sanjari who was arrested in early October for writing about conflicts between the Iranian police and supporters of the Shia cleric Ayatollah Boroujerdi.
Persecuted
Which is why Amnesty International (AI) is now asking bloggers across the world to support those who are persecuted for what they write online, through highlighting cases such as that of Kianoosh, and affirming their commitment to free speech and free press.
“Freedom of expression online is a right, not a privilege,” says an AI spokesperson.
The AI campaign is being presented at next month’s inaugural meeting of the Internet Governance Forum - a UN body established to debate national net policies.
AI is concerned at the ongoing campaign by some nations, such as China, to close down citizens’ access to independent news sources, through building firewalls and closing down websites.
Big business
Google and Yahoo, companies rich enough to afford to do better, have been complicit in these machinations - and heavily criticised for being such.
AI has set up a website - Irrepressible.info - to expose the means by which governments quash dissent and to expose the role of big business in helping these repressive governments control the flow of information.
Via this website, people can distribute material that is otherwise being repressed and keep the campaign alive and in the public eye.

—page four—

The last places on earth

by Roz Paterson

You may never have heard of some of these places, but between them, they account for over 10 million people and some of the worst human health catastrophes on earth.
The US-based Blacksmith Institute, an environmental charity, has charted the world’s ten most polluted places.
What is quite startling, aside from the horrendous footprint of unregulated industry, is that only one of them is at all familiar: Chernobyl, site of the worst nuclear accident on record, which drove hundreds of thousands from their homes, never to return, and is still being felt, punishingly, in childhood cancers, birth defects and premature deaths.
But Chernobyl is not the only place where everyone fears to tread.
Dzerzhinsk was once the centre of Russia’s chemical weapons industry, producing such horrors as lewisite, containing arsenic trioxide, and yperite (mustard gas).
Though weapons manufacture ceased in 1945, much of the toxic waste, often including high concentrations of arsenic, was dumped on the site of the factories, not all of which have been completely dismantled even yet.
The city continues to be a major chemicals producer and is horribly polluted, with an average life expectancy of only 42 years of age for men, 47 for women.
This low life expectancy has been attributed to high levels of persistent organic chemicals (or POPs), particularly dioxins, by certain environmental action groups including Greenpeace.
Further north, in fact inside the Arctic Circle, is Norilsk, the former Siberian slave labour colony established in 1935 and the world’s largest heavy metal smelting complex, which expels 4 million tonnes of cadmium, copper, lead, nickel, arsenic, selenium and zinc into the atmosphere every year.
Nickel is its main industry, and the former state company Norilsk Nickel is now in private hands, those of Interros, a less than shiny example of corporate responsibility, yet one which can boast an ex-senior official of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development on its board of directors and accountancy giant Deloitte and Touche as its auditors, according to campaign group Mines and Communities.
Though there’s not much to boast about if you’re a worker here, where wages are so low and house prices so pitiful that it’s near-impossible to escape, where the smoke from the streaming chimneys turns the air sulphurous and the snow yellow for 30 miles around, and where people die at 50, their bodies literally sick to death.
Descriptions of life here are reminiscent of Emile Zola’s Germinal.
Everyone is sick, but can’t admit it for fear of losing work.
Everyone shops at company-owned shops.
They live, work, reproduce for the company.
In 2002, a co-chairman of Norilsk Nickel somehow  became regional governor.
Norilsk became a ‘closed city’ in 2001, at a time when many former closed cities were opening up.
Norilsk cannot be accessed by foreigners, and gauging the effects of the pollution on human health is hard, though anecdotally it is known that children suffer the brunt, from low birth weights through to life-threatening respiratory problems.
Ecologists claim that the effects of the horrendous contamination of the atmosphere can be felt as far away as Norway and Canada.
Other identified sites include Linfen, China, at the heart of the coal industry.
Here, the coal dust is so thick in the evenings that people literally choke on it.
Cases of  bronchitis, pneumonia, and lung cancer are soaring, as are cases of severe lead poisoning in children, which is known to cause severe learning difficulties and developmental problems.
Says the Blacksmith Institute report:
“Living in a town with serious pollution is like living under a death sentence.
“If the damage does not come from immediate poisoning, then cancers, lung infections, mental retardation, are likely outcomes.
“There are some towns where life expectancy approaches medieval rates, where birth defects are the norm not the exception.
“In other places children’s asthma rates are measured above 90 per cent, or mental retardation is endemic.
“In these places, life expectancy may be half that of the richest nations.”
Also listed are Kabwe, in Zambia, a mining and smelting site, Haina, in the Dominican Republic, where battery recycling and smelting have led to a huge build-up of lead concentrations in the blood levels of local people, Ranipet, in India, where 3million people are affected by tannery waste, Rudnaya Pristan, in Russia, a former lead mining epicentre, La Oroya, in Peru, and Mailuu Suu, in Kyrghistan.
In La Oroya, dangerously high levels of lead in 99 per cent of children’s blood has been recorded by the Peruvian Ministry of Health, and attributed to toxic emissions from a poly-smelter owned by US company Doe Run corporation.
Suphur dioxide levels in human bodies are also hazardously high.
This chemical by-product has other attributes; it causes the acid rain that eats away the vegetation here, giving the area its barren look.
Some 35,000 people are affected, yet in 2004, Doe Run won a four year extension to its deadline to do anything about its emissions.
Mailuu Suu was the site of a Soviet uranium plant, operating from 1946-68, during which time 10,000 cubic metres of uranium ore was produced, much of it going towards the making of the USSR’s first atomic bomb.
This activity produced 1.96 million cubic metres of radioactive waste, which threatens the lives of all those who live in this once fertile valley.
That it is also an earthquake zone adds to residents’ fear that there are more disasters just waiting to happen.
The American Institute of Oncology and Radiology said, in 1999, that twice as many people here had cancer than elsewhere in Kyrghistan.
Says Robert Fuller, director of the Blacksmith Institute:
“A particular concern of all these cases is the accumulating and long lasting burden building up in the environment and in the bodies of the people most directly affected.”
UN research suggests that 20 per cent of premature deaths across the globe are borne of environmental factors.
“Our goal,” says Fuller, “is to instill a sense of urgency about tackling these priority sites.”
The Blacksmith Institute is involved in remediation programmes in some sites, but is desperately trying to stimulate action in others.
Action includes major projects, such as constructing water purifiers, to the relatively basic task of educating people on what contaminated waste looks like and why they should avoid it.
Though, looking at these devastated regions, avoiding toxic waste may be a somewhat fanciful notion without an air ticket out of there.

n For further info, see: www.minesandcommunities.org www.blacksmithinstitute.org

—page five—

letters page

Clutching at straws
In a recent interview former foreign secretary Jack Straw made some revealing remarks about the British union.
Straw is quoted on the BBC website as saying: “Historically, England called the shots to achieve a union because the union was seen as a way, among others things, of amplifying England’s power worldwide. And the reverse would certainly be true. A broken-up United Kingdom would not be in the interests of Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland, but especially not England.
“Our [England’s] voting power in the European Union would diminish. We’d slip down in the world league GDP tables. Our case for staying in the G8 would diminish and there could easily be an assault on our permanent seat in the UN [security council].”
We should be grateful to Straw for his honesty. What he is effectively saying is that countries like Scotland and Wales and other potential independent states such as Cornwall or the Isle of Man are expected to give up their unique voices in the international community so England can enjoy ‘amplified’, i.e. undeserved, international status.
The case for union then is simple if, like Gordon Brown, you support England’s interests over Scotland’s.
As Straw says, there is an excellent case for retention of the union because it was designed to amplify England’s voice and it still does today.
If however you support Scotland’s right to have our unique voice heard then the only logical choice is independence.
If the ‘cost’ of that decision is the loss of Britain’s (as Straw points out effectively England’s anyway) seat in the UN security council, which the Blair government currently uses to back George Bush’s lunatic foreign policy, then I’m sure that is a price well worth paying for any internationally minded Scot.
Joe Middleton,
Edinburgh

Trial by media
Paul McCartney - Beatle, composer, lovable Scouser and all-round saint. How we all ooh-ed and aah-ed when the glossy wedding snaps hit the press back in 2002 when he tied the knot with charity golden girl and celebrity disabled-person Heather Mills. Saint Paul, marrying again after the loss of first wife Linda, this time to a former model some 25 years his junior.
Sadly, the honeymoon is well and truly over and the celebrity couple have hit the papers as a messy and expensive divorce case looms.
Heather Mills McCartney is far from the first woman to find herself up against not only her former husband but the badmouthing of his friends and family, but few can experience it as publicly.
A glittering array of stars have opened their hearts to the gutter press to tell how ‘their’ Paul would never, could never, be an abusive man. After all, he was in the Beatles!
No one knows what went on behind closed doors during the brief years of their marriage, and Sir Paul has denied claims that he stabbed his partner with a broken wine glass, forced her into a bath and objected to her breastfeeding their child.
But Mills McCartney has been vilified the length and breadth of the country, with newspapers claiming that she had worked in the sex industry, and McCartney’s friends lining up to denounce her as a gold-digger and fantasist.
Most recently, Jonathon Ross called her a “liar” during a music awards ceremony, joking about her prosthetic leg.
Ross’ comments - as well as being in appallingly bad taste - leave no doubt as to whose side The Great British Public (aka the Man in the Street) are on in this battle.
The message to women? If your man is rich, famous, charismatic and respected, watch out.
If, as Mills McCartney claims, she experienced domestic abuse, she faces a huge, uphill battle against the misogyny of the media before she even steps into a courtroom to seek justice for herself and her child.
Pam Currie, Glasgow

Oppose Trident, by any means necessary
In her article, ‘The Cost of Protest’ (Voice 284), Morag Balfour continues to argue that the SSP should not get involved in Faslane 365, out of concern for the local community and the survival of small businesses in the area.
I have to disagree and fully support the recent conference decision which mandated the EC to organise the SSP’s involvement in Faslane 365.
Although civil disobedience, strikes, pickets, boycotts and other forms of protest are aimed at governments, employers, multinationals and those in authority, other people do get caught in the cross-fire. However, this has never prevented socialists from joining and supporting those in struggle.
I do agree that we need to listen and talk to local people and make them aware of why we are doing what we are doing. We need to engage with them. Leafleting the area and public meetings explaining our anti-nuclear stance and our ideas for developing economic alternatives to military spending must form part of building for our participation in the blockade.
When I lived at Faslane Peace camp, there was extreme hostility from those who worked in the base and people who lived locally. Influenced by the right wing press they saw us as the enemy and, egged on by the local Tories, campaigned to have the camp closed. You may find the arguments used against the camp’s presence familiar. Jobs will go if the camp is successful, the camp will have a negative effect on tourism and local businesses.
We worked hard at explaining that we were against the government and nuclear weapons, and not them as individuals. Over the years the peace camp has become an accepted part of the community with a valid role as a witness for peace.
Haldane is a deprived community in West Dunbartonshire on the route used to transport nuclear warheads. Regular actions, including blockades, take place at a large roundabout on the main road to Stirling causing traffic jams and a degree of disruption for pedestrians. There is always a large police prese nce.
Initially there was a lot of aggro from all quarters of the community. However, we worked hard at leafleting the cars and pedestrians caught up in the blockades, explaining why we were there and what the vehicles were carrying.
The effect on the locals has been very positive. Because of the large police presence local people now know when the convoy is due and stand at the side of the road sometimes shouting encouragement.
They also ask senior police officers at community meetings why are there not enough police officers to patrol their community when there are always plenty of officers to guard the nuclear convoy.
There are many different roads to peace and disarmament and we must respect and support the contributions made by all.
Conferences, peace education, lobbying, writing letters and civil resistance are all valid forms that should not be seen as competing with each other but complementing each other.
I hope that Morag’s article will act as a catalyst for further discussion on the whole question of peace and disarmament and that she reconsiders her decision to resign as the SSP’s Peace and Disarmament spokesperson.
Les Robertson, Dumbarton

GIE’S PEACE
Morag Balfour

Join the Army?

A quick listen to local radio can teach a person many things. I tuned in briefly to our local station last week and found out the following; their play-list is still pathetic, there really is nothing happening in my town, and the Army recruitment machine is exploiting the hell out of anodyne radio broadcasting. A Scot with an affected American twang boomed thus ‘Join Marie-Claire live at Dreghorn Barracks and experience Army life’. They promised paintball, and other murder simulation ‘sports’. The notion ‘earn money, take part in great sports and see the world’ sounds great if you are 16, living in poverty, and bored witless.
It’s what they don’t say in their chirpy recruitment drives that scares and angers me most. ‘Earn money’ means they’ve bought you, body and soul, and you become a disposable unit.
God forbid that you ever work out that you are being asked to commit a war crime, as an objection from you can get you court-martialled. ‘Great sports’ ends up meaning killing people with brown skin indiscriminately. ‘See the world’ translates as see the world as and when we choose to destroy or manipulate it, leave it barren, radioactive or littered with bomblets - life-threatening debris, a lasting consequence of our excessive use of the cluster bomb.
I went to see a play with my Mum recently. To be honest with you I’m surprised we actually got round to going.
We have lots of good intentions but rarely synchronise diaries and buy tickets ahead of time. This particular play mattered to both of us. This play was Not About Heroes by Stephen MacDonald. Set during the First World War it charts the relationship between poets Siegfried Sassoon and Wilfred Owen. The two men met at Craiglockhart War Hospital.
Owen had ‘broken down’ and Sassoon was sent there in an attempt to silence his protests against the seemingly never-ending war. They were both traumatised by the experience of trench warfare. A friend standing next to you is there one second, and the next he’s gone, and it’s your job to put what’s left of him in a sack.
I was fairly familiar with the story and some of the featured poems. Some years ago a friend recommended that I read Pat Barker’s Regeneration trilogy. I couldn’t put those books down.
Even now I can recall many of the images her writing inspired. We desperately need to be connected to an honest view of what war does to people. Both Mum and I left the theatre with a strengthened belief that no side really wins in a war.
And so I come back to the parasites from Army Recruitment. They prey on the young and they are damn good at it. Look away for a second and they’ve come up with yet another way to ingratiate themselves on an unsuspecting public. From sponsoring women’s football to taking youth groups paint-balling, you name it and these creatures are probably doing it. Where exactly does child protection come into the picture? Unfortunately it doesn’t. More and more schools let the military run amok with their weans. Wherever I see one of their posters I discreetly take it down and recycle it. I prefer it if nobody notices that I’ve done it. Months may go by before they ‘fix it’. I’m still angry with myself for not challenging their methods and message more actively.
Squirting paint at someone hardly gives a realistic experience of actually killing someone. My God, why would anyone want a realistic experience of it? I think the time is ripe for a concerted and organised campaign against these bastards. If they’re active in your neck of the woods then give ‘em hell, then let the rest of us know what they’re up to.

—centre pages—

Beneath the rubble

Rana Al-aiouby carries bodies out from flattened Iraqi homes, and she carries medicine into plundered, crumbling Iraqi hospitals.
She has brought documentation of atrocities committed by the occupying American military, which gives the lie to claims that those war crimes we hear of are isolated incidents.
Rana spoke to Eddie Truman while in Scotland as part of efforts to build practical solidarity between the two countries.
In normal times, Rana Al-aiouby would be studying. She already has a degree in French literature and was teaching French but wanted to continue her university education, perhaps doing postgraduate studies and learning Spanish.
But in 2003, the Americans and British invaded Iraq and changed the course of her life forever.
Now Rana takes medical supplies into towns and cities under siege by the occupation forces in Iraq, and takes out those women and children who are willing and able to leave.
Asked about her family background, Rana says that, like many Iraqis, her family descends from a mix of different geographical and social backgrounds.
She is proud of her surname, Al-aiouby.
“Do you know who this is I am descended from?
“Selahedîn Ayûbî, the world’s first terrorist!”
“Freedom fighter,” I say.
“Yes, the only man to liberate Jerusalem.
“My mother and father are both from Baghdad, my grandmother on my mother’s side is from Fallujah.”
Fallujah is a name that appears regularly throughout my discussions with Rana.
Forty-three miles west of Baghdad, with a pre-invasion population of 350,000, the town hit world news headlines when it was besieged twice by the Americans.
‘The first siege of Fallujah’ has become both a symbol of the inhumanity of the occupation armies and of the spirit of resistance of the Iraqis.
Bringing wounded women and children out of the city, Rana became a news story herself when the ambulance she was in was shot at by American troops.
We talk for a while about the huge social benefits brought to Iraq by the Baathist revolution of 1968 and the nationalisation of Iraq’s oil industry - Iraq became the best educated country in the Middle East, and its citizens had access to free health care.
“We were brought up with the basic demands of the Baathist revolution; that there should be one unified state for the Arab people and the idea of unity, freedom and socialism.
“When the Americans invaded, I started working as a translator for the media, but when the terrible sieges began I started doing what I could to help with humanitarian work.
“Working in the conflict area we would evacuate women and children, literally from under the bombing.”
The organisation that Rana now runs with the help of activists from the US, Europe and Scotland, was born during the second siege of Fallujah, when an American aid worker saw her carrying boxes of medical supplies through an American checkpoint and suggested Rana form her own aid organisation.
It was named International Peace Angels, and while other NGOs pull out their workers when the fighting begins, Rana goes to wherever people need help, even if there are American snipers picking off anything that moves.
“Whenever a town is put under siege, the Americans put snipers on vantage points and they shoot anything that moves on the streets; men, women, animals,” she says, “even if they are carrying a white flag.
“All the major Iraq cities are now surrounded by checkpoints and they will suddenly close them. Nothing gets out, nothing gets in. People can’t go to work, get supplies or anything.”
For Rana it is the situation faced by women and children under the occupation that pushes her to continue her work.
She cites the fact that 30,000 women have had miscarriages because of the state of fear they are living under.
A further 1,500 women have had miscarriages as a direct result of a beating from occupying soldiers.
“Sometimes when I think about it afterwards, the blood and the bodies, it is not easy, I wonder how I was able to do something like that. But you have to do it.
“This is what I believe; that even if I get shot and lose my life, if I have saved one life then I have done the right thing, if I have saved more than one life before I lose my own, then I will have won.
“And I wish I could do more, we have been created to help each other, not to sit about keeping our brains warm.”
The occupation forces have been involved in some of the most appalling war crimes against Iraqi women and children.
Rana goes over the details surrounding the rape and murder of 14 year old Abeer Qassim al-Janabi in Mahmoudiya earlier this year.
Abeer had been sexually harassed by a group of US soldiers at the checkpoint she had to go through every day. Then one afternoon they came looking for her, raped her and killed her and her family afterwards.
Rana reads the details, carefully taken in testimony from friends and neighbours, from a notebook, with the full names and dates of birth of all those killed.
The details are horrific.
It was to become a worldwide news story, with the American military desperate to paint this as a one-off incident, but Rana has arrived in the UK with the same methodical documentation of other atrocities committed by occupation forces.
On 4 May of this year an American patrol was hit by a roadside bomb in Samarra’a. Very quickly the area was the subject a huge military operation.
The Zaidan family, 14 in all, took shelter in what they thought would be the safest room in the house.
Twenty American soldiers entered the house, shouting and abusing the family. Dragging the father outside, they then start to execute the family, shooting the Grandmother through the eye in front of the children.
The two youngest girls are the only ones who survive unscathed, along with the wounded nephew of one of the women killed.
Rana shows me pictures of the wall of the room splattered with blood and pieces of brain, and the blood soaked book of one of the children.
“We hate the Americans because they killed our Grandma, our Uncle and our Aunt.”
On 6 May 2006, again in Samarra’a, a big American patrol raided the house of Atif Abed Khalaf, his wife and their four children.
At 7am the Americans took Atif outside, while the family watched from the kitchen window, and executed him.
Rana shows me pictures of different calibre bullet holes in the wall; more than one soldier had done the shooting.
On 3 January 2004 Zaidoun Fadel Hassoun was on the way back to Samarra’a with his cousin.
They were stopped by an American patrol after their truck broke down and the two were taken in handcuffs to the edge of the river - where they were told to jump in.
Zaidoun pled with the soldiers that he was unable to swim but was pushed in and drowned.
His cousin survived and related the story to his mother, who launched a campaign to bring the soldiers to justice.
The pictures that Rana brings, the interviews with survivors and witnesses, though they are in-depth and meticulous, give just a glimpse of the brutality meted out everyday on Iraq’s streets and in Iraqi people’s homes.
This is what occupation means, and this is the occupation in which Britain’s troops play a part.
And for every day occupation continues, their will be another Zaidan family, another Atif, another Zaidoun.

Cannon fodder kids

by Carol Hainey

A Falkirk mother has received an apology from a school headmaster, after her children were handed over to the army for a day, in the teeth of her repeated objections
Her children, aged 11 and 12, were compelled to take part in exercises that included ‘imagining they were in a minefield’ and ‘acting injured’.
A soldier participating made the crude remark that he was, “having more trouble with you lot than with Iraqi terrorists”. 
The incident took place at the Graeme High Summer School, despite the mother previously stating that she did not want her children to attend any school events where the military were present.
The woman, who declined to be named in order to protect the identity of her children, alleges that during the exercise, the children felt bullied by inappropriate comments from the soldiers, as well as disturbed by the nature of some of the activities involved.
She claims the soldiers belittled the efforts of the children, telling them they were ‘rubbish’ and ‘unbelievably slow’.
She has been a long-term opponent of military recruiters in schools, and told members of the local SSP branch about information she has uncovered regarding military involvement in schools and her attempts to make education chiefs respond to this.
“I don’t think they should be there, when there is a war going on. But the...school seems to be...happy for the army to be there. That it’s just an ordinary job, an ordinary service. I’m totally against that.
“Children are discouraged from smoking or having sex, at least until they are 16. They are considered too young to vote or to view the most violent films until they are 18.
“So how can it possibly be acceptable to expose them to the idea of a job where they may kill or be killed, when they are only 12 to 16 years old? There was even an instance where someone from the army was at the primary school.”
She says the Army is “not like other organisations and I fear treating them as such will encourage children to see killing and bombing as something natural and normal, which it isn’t.
“It would be a shame if some of the children were being encouraged to join the military rather than continue their education for as long as possible.”
She is keen to point out that she has nothing against serving soldiers.
“They go into it thinking they are doing something good and once they are signed up they no longer have a choice. Blair lied to them too. It’s people lying to children, getting them interested in signing up without telling them the full facts of the horror of war, that I am opposed to. 
“I have read that once they sign up, if they are over 18, they can get a life sentence if they refuse to go to Iraq. They should be told about the lack of proper equipment before they are encouraged to join.”
She refers to a document called The Future Strategic Context for Defence.
“It is chilling. It explains how the Government needs to spin conflict to make it seem like war is humanitarian and in our best interests. So much money is spent on MOD spin.
“But war is wrong. I have to do something about it. We have to bring up our kids to feel that there is a point in challenging what is wrong.”
She recently received a poignant message of support to give to the school from Rose Gentle, whose son Gordon died in Iraq, aged only 19, after joining the army to escape poverty.
Rose wrote: “Gordon was told that he would get his driving licence and his training to be a motor mechanic, but after 24 weeks’ training, he was sent to Iraq and killed within three weeks.
“If a kid wants to go into the army, then when he or she leaves school, they can go to the recruiting office.
“But kids just now are getting killed for what? I don’t think letting the recruitment into the school should be allowed...
“I think the kids should be left alone until they are old enough to think what they really want to do.
“Remember these are just kids and so was my son, 19.”
The Falkirk parent believes activities of school military recruiters are enhanced by the presence of an organisation called Skill Force.
On their website, Skill Force claim to have been set up, in 2000, because every year many highly trained instructors who have worked with and mentored young people, leave the armed forces and return to civilian life.
It suggests that some of these former instructors could work with young people in schools to develop their self-esteem, problem-solving and team-working skills, as part of the emerging alternative curriculum.
The scheme was piloted in Scotland, in North Lanarkshire, in 2001, subsequently expanding rapidly across the UK.
In 2004, Skill Force distanced itself from the MoD, by registering as a not-for-profit company with the Charities Commission.
Two research reports have been produced on the Skill Force pilot projects, which in general praise Skill Force for helping pupils towards gaining non-academic awards, such as first aid and sporting certificates.
However, one revealed: “A secondary aim of the programme is to improve perceptions among pupils and other stakeholders about the role and value of the Armed Forces, to enhance their appeal as employers and their value to society in the general.”
Follow-up studies suggest they have been successful in this, with 75 per cent reporting an increased understanding of the Armed Forces, and 49 per cent expresssing an interest in joining up, compared to 15 per cent previously.
Concerns expressed by teachers are included in another report, for example: “I can’t trust them to handle parents’ evenings without my presence. It would turn into an army recruitment drive.”
A Hansard account of military recruitment in schools being discussed in the House of Commons, from October 2001, finds Defence spokesman, Dr Lewis Moonie, admitting: “...We also have a programme called Outreach, in which cadet forces work with youngsters who may have  problems in order to introduce them to life in the cadets.
“The programme has had remarkable success in producing recruits to the armed forces.”
He continues: “We have also developed a concept called Skill Force...”
The mum said: “I have real concerns about this. I’m sure many of these instructors are committed to helping young people, but as a parent I have to question why this has been done in this way, at this time.
“Why has Skill Force been introduced in schools where there is a lot of poverty?
“Skill Force have achieved these results by working with smaller groups of students, much smaller than normal class sizes. They also do things the kids love, like a lot of outdoor education.”
 She continued: “Skill Force claim that their connection with the armed forces is one of their greatest strengths, giving them credibility with disaffected students, particularly boys, but no research has been done to compare that to anything. 
“All occupations train young people, so maybe instructors from any walk of life, for example health care workers or environmental protection workers, could have achieved similar results, given the resources that Skill Force have.”
Skill Force had complained that they only got the “difficult kids” to work with.
Now, it seems, this has changed and they have “access to every pupil.”
Couldn’t the resources at Skill Force’s disposal be better used, she asks, “to reduce class sizes and give teachers more of a free reign?
“To sometimes do fun things with pupils, instead of a strict curriculum?”
In the course of her researches, this inspiring woman has also uncovered a link between school meals and the war in Iraq.
She says: “Scolarest, which provides the food for the PFI-funded Graeme High School, is the sister company of Eurest, which provides food for soldiers in Iraq.
“They are both part of the catering giant Compass, which paid £40 million to settle two American lawsuits alleging it engaged in ‘criminal conspiracy’ to win United Nations food service contracts.
“They also sacked some staff, in relation to that.
“The Compass group say that the £40 million settlement is not an admission of liability. Eurest has been criticised for providing poor quality and inadequate amounts of food for the soldiers in Iraq, and for paying workers as little as $3 a day, despite making millions in profit.”
She notes that the company has also been condemned for its junk food menu.
Some schools in Camden, for instance, opted out of a contract with Scolarest, after a report found the company’s food failed to meet basic nutritional standards.
“It seems that we are nothing but a raw human resource, or a source of profit, for Bush and Blair and the people they serve.
“This company is making money out of war in Iraq and also from a PFI contract in our school.”
She urges all parents to ask questions and demand the best for their children.
“School boards are being done away with next year. They are being replaced by parents’ forums.
“I don’t know what rights we will have, but at least it will give us all a voice and we should use it.”
She concludes: “I have to do this. I have to speak out. If I told my children I couldn’t do anything about these things, they would grow up fearful.”

 

—page eight—

Hold Executive to account over prescription promises

by Colin Fox

In February of this year - on the very day the Scottish Parliament was due to debate the SSP bill to abolish NHS prescription charges, to be exact - the Executive announced a package of reforms intended to offset the chances of a backbench rebellion.
They promised to review the impact the charges had on the chronically sick and on students in full time education and training.
That review is now complete. It is in the hands of the Deputy Health Minister Lewis Macdonald and interest in its findings is intense.
That he is reportedly reluctant to publish can perhaps be understood because most health experts and commentators are keen to see how the Executive have solved a conundrum which has evaded them for nearly half a century.
The list of chronic conditions that are exempt from prescription charges has not been changed since 1964. In 40 years, health professionals and politicians alike have not been able to find an appropriate and logical reason to exempt one chronic condition, which allows for one group of patients to get their medicines free, whilst not including another group.
Nonetheless this Executive has promised and must now come forward with an answer, to explain why a Parkinson’s Disease sufferer is exempt when an asthmatic is not, why a patient with a chronic skin complaint will be exempt, but cancer patients must continue to pay.
It is not something the Executive was able to do in the six months of intensive parliamentary scrutiny that my Bill went through in 2005.
The concessions promised in February will also look rather foolish unless they can also justify why students in full time education and training should be exempt, but part time students are not.
Or, since the student exemption is at least based on an acceptance that there are those who simply cannot afford the £6.60 charge per item of prescription, why only students?
Why not the low paid who run the risk of going without their medicines? Or those on Incapacity Benefit or Disability Living Allowance? Why must these groups of poor people continue to have to pay?
The prescription charges system is a complete and utter dogs dinner which sees the 30 MSPs who are over the age of 65 get medicines free, but 300,000 people on Incapacity and DLA forced to pay.
Whatever the Scottish Executive’s review concludes, the unfortunate truth is that tens of thousands of Scots will still be forced to go without the medicines they need because the simply cannot afford the £6.60 per item demanded of them.
That undermines the core commitment the NHS promised us all - universal free healthcare.
Perhaps the Executive should just come clean and admit their policy amounts to keeping medicines out of reach - of the poor.

Rosie Kane jailed for nuke demo

As the Voice goes to press, SSP MSP Rosie Kane is nearing the end of a week in Cornton Vale women’s prison, after a harsh 14-day sentence was handed down last week.
Rosie was jailed after refusing, on grounds of conscience, to pay a £300 fine for her part in an anti-Trident missile protest at the Scottish Parliament last year.
The MSP for Glasgow was involved in occupying a model submarine on the road in front of the Holyrood building which disrupted traffic for several hours.
She was the only one of ten charged at the protest to receive a jail sentence.
Speaking in court before sentence, Rosie said:
“I was involved in a protest, it was act of conscience, against the Scottish Parliament’s inability or unwillingness to do anything about nuclear weapons. For that reason I can’t, and won’t pay the fine.”
See next week’s Voice for Rosie’s story from inside Cornton Vale.

Socialists protest at nuclear waste trains

To highlight the fact that nuclear waste trains, en route from Hunterston to Sellafield, are routed through Paisley, the Renfrewshire Branch of the Scottish Socialist Party held a protest on Sunday 22 October in County Square, outside Paisley Gilmour Street train station.
The demo is part of a  series of events to promote their ‘People not Profit’ campaign.
John Miller, press officer for the SSP branch, said:
“These trains run right through Renfrewshire, including Elderslie and Johnstone, but the problem is probably worse at Gilmour Street since there has already been a speed restriction in force for some considerable time due to track maintenance problems.”
Iain Hogg, Branch Chair, added:
“It’s really not good enough that we discover these things thanks to the persistence of Greenpeace.
“Nuclear waste should not be dragged all around the country on trains running through population centres. We are not trying to scaremonger but the implications of this policy are fairly obvious.
“Energy should be produced as near as possible to where it is to be consumed and any waste should be treated as near as possible to the point of production. Anything else makes little sense.”

—page nine—

Looking down on life

Red Road (18) Directed by Andrea Arnold
At cinemas now

Andrea Arnold won the Prix de Jury at this years Cannes Film Festival for this her first feature. She had already won an Oscar for her short film Wasp last year.
Red Road is a production of The Advance Party, a Scottish/Danish collaboration with somewhat Dogme style restrictions on filming.
The movie is part of a trilogy, Red Road being the first.
All three will be set in Glasgow, using the same set of characters, with each film directed by a different director, and shot within a six week period.
The main character in the film is Jackie (Kate Dickie) who works as a CCTV operative. Using her TV monitor the same way as James Stewart used his Rear Window in the Hitchcock classic, she observes the world pass by.
Her mundane life is interrupted when she spots Clyde, a face from her past.
It soon becomes apparent that Jackie and Clyde share a dark and painful history - a history that has lead to Jackie’s joyless existence.
Jackie becomes obsessed by Clyde’s life, stalking him, gate-crashing his party and befriending his flatmates. Her obsession grows and it becomes blurred as to whether she wants to kill Clyde or sleep with him. We become more and more involved with her pursuit of the man from her past.
You do not find out till near the end of the film what tragic events connect Jackie and Clyde.
The movie has a dark repressive feel, with its use of CCTV imagery and centred around the imposing tower blocks of the title.
Despite this Arnold keeps you emotionally involved with her subjects’ lives.
Overall Red Road is film well worth seeking out, with powerful performances from those involved.
The film deserves the plaudits it has received giving us a strong incite into the power that grief can have on a person and how easy that persons grief can be overlooked in our constantly observed CCTV world.

Wanlockhead: a mine of information

It’s one of the most isolated museums in Scotland, located high above the Leadhills near, well, nowhere really. Yet the Lead Mining Museum at Wanlockhead, in Dumfries and Galloway, is Scotland’s only comprehensive memorial to an industry that dominated the 18th and 19th centuries.
Opened in 1974, the museum welcomes 15,000 visitors a year, despite its location, which serves as testament to the fascination that people’s history holds.
Yet the museum’s trustees had no option but to issue a warning recently that it would close its doors for 2007 if financial aid did not arrive in time.
Thus, the physical isolation that has seen the community dwindle to mere dozens since the days when they carved the lead ore from these hills like it was butter, and everyone without exception lived, breathed and died for the mining concessions, could also put paid to its historical marker.
But rescue may be at hand.
A new initiative, the Significance Scheme, has thrown the museum a lifeline.
Established by the Scottish Museums Council and dedicated to the preservation of non-national museums and galleries of public importance, the Significance Scheme could put enough funding Wanlockhead’s way to keep it open for years to come.
Like so many arts concerns, the museum has had to rely on piecemeal funding from a variety of sources, making it impossible to budget properly and plan for the future. This funding could change all that.
Wanlockhead was once at the centre of the richest lead mining area in the country and the museum preserves one of these mines, the Lochnell, so that modern-day visitors can experience for themselves the close darkness of a miner’s life.
Though they are spared the deadeningly hard graft, daily life-threatening danger and wretched wages system that went with it.
Lead miners did get paid relatively well - £10-£20 a year compared to £5 for a farm labourer - but were made to wait until the ore they mined was smelted and sold in Europe before they got their pay. This process could take up to two years.
Here’s hoping the museum won’t have to wait that long.

n www.leadminingmuseum.co.uk

Powerful words on war

Radio 3, in a break with tradition, is to schedule a week’s programming around a literary, rather than musical, artist - Wilfred Owen, whose poems bring home the full horror of trench warfare, and the aching sadness of so much loss for a base lie, that to die for your country is an honour and a privilege.
Owen was born in Shropshire, to working-class parents. Though his literary talent shone early, he found his path to higher education blocked by his inability to pay for it.
When the First World War broke out, he enlisted, serving in the Manchester Regiment, which saw battle at the Somme, the first day of which witnessed the biggest loss of life in the entire war. He himself was trapped in a shell-hole for three days and was subsequently diagnosed with shell-shock; a devastating condition now known as Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder.
He was dispatched to Craiglockhart Hospital, near Edinburgh, to recuperate and there met the poet Seigfried Sassoon, who was to have a profound effect on Owen’s work, leading him towards the realist style which informs his greatest poems.
Much to Sassoon’s dismay, Owen returned to the front upon his discharge from hospital. He felt that, as others had to, so should he. He was killed in action, and his parents received the telegram announcing his death on Armistice Day. This brutal irony casts a shadow over his brilliance, bringing home the reality of war; that death is final and forever, no matter who you could have been.
Radio 3’s week, which runs from 12-19 November, features readings of his complete war poems, including stalwarts such as Dulce Et Decorum Est and Anthem For Doomed Youth, as well as lesser thumbed works such as Spring Offensive and Mental Cases.
The schedule also includes a new choral work, by Judith Bingham, based on the poet’s often heartbreakingly stout-spirited letters home, and the voices of soldiers who served in Northern Ireland and Iraq describing the impact of reading Owen’s works for themselves.

Tuned in
Keef Tomkinson

Saturday 4 November
The Culture Show, BBC2 7:15pm
Fifties throwback film critic, Mark Kermode, talks to Steven Spielberg about his career, favourite films and influences. The most successful director in history, he is often criticised for a lack of innovation yet he has made many of the most memorable films of the last 30 years.

Sunday 5 November
The Clash: Westway to the World, ITV4 10:55pm
Aren’t there more Clash documentaries than there are socialists in the Labour party? Who cares when we get the chance to see and hear them in action?

Monday 6 November
Days of Heaven, Film4 7:15pm
Terence Malik has made three other films: Badlands one of the best films of the 20th Century, the hypnotic anti-war drama The Thin Red Line Line, and recent masterpiece The New World. This tale of love and poverty in the wheatfields of Texas stars Sam Shepherd and a young Richard Gere.
Lock Them Up or Let Them Out, BBC2 9:00pm
If this is not sensationalist then it could actually be of some interest. This documentary follows three prisoners on their battle for parole. They are a murderer, armed robber and a firebomber. Before you ask - you don’t get to text a vote to decide who goes free!

Wednesday 8 November
True Stories: Bright Leaves, More4 9:00pm
Ross McElwee’s documentary is set in North Carolina and examines the tobacco industry from its humble roots to the position of one of the most hated and distrusted industries in the world.

Friday 10 November
Nation on Film: Women’s Football, BBC4 8:30pm
The story of the Dick Kerr Ladies whose WWI munitions football team became a national hit before the English FA banned women’s football from league grounds for 50 years.

—page ten—

international news

Military graduates condemn bush

by Ken Ferguson

Growing opposition to the Bush war drive and the mayhem it is creating in Iraq has spread to the heart of the US military with the foundation of Service Academy Graduates Against the War (SAGAW).
Founded by three 1962 graduates of the elite West Point Military Academy - the US equivalent of Sandhurst - SAGAW takes in graduates from the Marines, Army, Air Force and Navy, the heart of the US military’s officer corps.
The new organisation calls on graduates of all service academies to speak out against the abuse of military power by the Bush regime and what they see as the destruction of the honour and reputation of the United States.
Clearly the group can hardly be written off by the increasingly under pressure neo-cons behind the Iraq blunder as a bunch of peaceniks, since all have years of service in the US military.
Given their background their attacks on the war make startling reading, with criticisms of the corrosive impact of the illegal war on morale in the military.
For many of the supporters of SAGAW this has uneasy echoes of what happened during the Vietnam war when the military went from being heroes to the focus of mass protest across the world.
Indeed one of the key objectives set by the Bush administration for taking out Saddam was to bury the so called ‘Vietnam syndrome’, which claimed that the impact of the 1976 defeat made the US unwilling to go to war anywhere.
Well, whatever else it has achieved, the bloody adventure in Iraq with its rapidly escalating US death toll alongside the mass slaughter of the ‘liberated’ Iraqis has failed to make it easier to deploy troops in new imperialist wars.

Impeachment
Perhaps the most significant demand of the organisation is its call for the impeachment of the president of the United States for high crimes and misdemeanours.
Again during the Vietnam era it was the threat of impeachment over the Watergate scandal which forced the resignation of the right wing President Richard Nixon in disgrace.
Some campaigners argue that Nixon’s crimes, bugging his opponents and using political dirty tricks, compare favourably with the mass slaughter of Bush’s ‘war on terror’.
SAGAW say it is the administration’s lying, cheating, stealing, delivering evasive statements and quibbling which has put vast numbers of innocent people in deadly peril and disgracefully diminished the integrity of the United States.
“660,000 people slaughtered,” said James Ryan, one of the founders, “and still no-one in the US government is held accountable for this crime against humanity.”
Their new website painstakingly documents the illegality of the assault on Iraq and the lies and subterfuge perpetrated by the president of the United States and his subordinates.
“All service academy grads should be concerned about the illegality of orders premised on the lies of the president,” said Dud Hendrick, a US Naval Academy graduate.
“We also serve to protect our fighting men and women from being subject to illegal and immoral orders.”

‘Meltdown’ predicted for US mid-term elections

by Roz Paterson

The American mid-term elections, which decide who runs Congress - currently controlled by the Republicans, take place on 7 November and already, before a single vote is cast, they have run into trouble.
An independent clearinghouse, Electionline.org, has warned that at least ten states, including Maryland, are heading for the kind of electoral meltdown we first saw in Florida 2000.
This time around, in place of hanging chads and, oh yes, all those fake felons bounced off the voters’ roll, there is a whole slew of new ways in which voters, particularly those in poor and black areas, will find themselves abruptly disenfranchised, from unreliable electronic voting machines to bylaws demanding specific new forms of ID to, of course, bouncing fake felons off the voters’ roll.
Electionline.org says the elections “promise to bring... a divided body politic, an election system in flux and the possibility, if not certainty, of problems at polls nationwide.”
In Indiana and Arizona, a court has upheld that voters may be required by poll workers to show very specific forms of ID. Too bad if they don’t have it to hand.
In Ohio and Pennsylvania, a new generation of voting machines has been introduced - unfortunately their accuracy is questionable and as there is little likelihood of a paper ballot back-up, there is even less of a chance of a recount.
Meanwhile, in Colorado and Washington, polling sites in neighbourhood precincts have been dispensed with, meaning many citizens will have to travel considerable distances in order to vote. Not so easy if you’re shift-working or have no transport or, to put it another way, are working-class and likely to vote Democrat.
As for Maryland, it held a “dismal primary” in September that “included human and machine failures galore”. For instance, Montgomery County officials forgot to distribute the access cards needed to make the newly installed machinery actually work. Doh. Not only that, but screens froze and, yep, ballots went a-missing.
The effects of which are not confined to that primary; come the general election next week, and voters cannot but be mistrustful of the whole process. They have every reason to be. A consequence of which could be a vastly reduced voter turn-out.
The National Association for the Advancement of Coloured People (NAACP) are not leaving it to chance. They intend to monitor ten states where there has previously been trouble round election time.

 

—page eleven—

international news

The disappearing islands

on the front line of global warming

When we talk of rising seas swamping land masses, we usually think of Bangladesh, Vietnam and parts of India and China, but the chains of islands strung out across the South Pacific will be the first victims of our insatiable appetite for fossil fuel energy.
Anote Tong, president of Kiribati, an equatorial archipelago of 33 coral atolls barely six feet above sea level and home to 100,000 people, warned there may have to be a major exodus within a decade.
At the annual South Pacific Forum summit last week, he indicated that Australia and New Zealand should be prepared to help resettle people from not only Kiribati but also from Vanuato, where an entire coastal village has already been evacuated, Tuvalu, the Marshall Islands and parts of Papua New Guinea, which are also threatened by rising seas.
“If we are talking about our island states submerging in ten years’ time, we simply have to find somewhere else to go.”
Most of Kiribati’s population live on Tarawa, a chain of islets encircling a lagoon. The beaches have become so eroded that sand has had to be imported from Australia.
Yet people are still uprooting their huts and rebuilding them further and further back from the sea. This cannot go on indefinitely, as the islets are becoming perilously narrow.
Tuvalu, with a population of 10,000, is also in dire straits.
“Our islands are very flat, as flat as a table,” Paani Laupepa, a Tuvalu delegate told the South Pacific Forum.
“It will be the whole population, the entire 10,000 people will be affected. We have a right to live in this environment and are being forced away.”
There has been considerable population drift already, with 17,000 Pacific islanders applying for residence in New Zealand in the last two years, compared to only 4000 in 2003.
As with most environmental catastrophe, rising seas are visited disproportionately on poorer nations, who have made the least contribution to global warming and have the fewest resources to deal with its consequences.
But while New Zealand has been quite helpful, Australia, a rich, gas-guzzling nation that famously refused to sign up to the Kyoto Protocol, has spurned requests to help resettle people, instead talking unrealistically about helping people to stay where they are.
Yet it is the actions of nations like Australia, and the UK, which have caused the incremental rise of the tide that could soon threaten the very ground on which hundreds of millions of people stand on.
Says Laupepa:
“We are deeply concerned. Certainly they have a moral obligation to take responsibility for the problems created by their actions.”

A year since the Paris revolt, and little has changed in the schemes

by Murray Smith, in Paris

Just one year ago, two young teenagers were accidentally electrocuted while trying to escape pursuing police.
The incident sparked off what the mainstream media and politicians called ‘the riots’. In fact it was a revolt of youth, mostly the children of immigrants from North and sub-Saharan Africa, in the poor housing schemes on the outskirts of France’s towns and cities, known as the banlieues.
For three weeks they burned cars and buses, and attacked police stations and any other symbol of the society that largely rejects them.
The incident that set off the revolt took place in the Parisian suburb of Clichy-sous-Bois, where 20 per cent of the population is unemployed - double the national average. In some neighbourhoods that rises to half the population.
There is nothing particular about Clichy - there are hundreds of places like it all over France. And most of the young unemployed are of immigrant origin.
An experiment by the University of Paris showed that with identical qualifications someone with a North African name was fives times less likely to get a job than someone with a typically ‘French’ one.
One year on, buses and cars are burning again and there are clashes between young people and the police. Not on the same scale as a year ago, but enough to remind French society that the banlieues are still there and that nothing much has changed.
The media are full of learned dissertations on the causes of last year’s revolt. Blame is attributed to the parents, to Islamic fundamentalism, criminal gangs and whatever.
Most of it ignores the simple equation:
unemployment + poverty + racism = revolt.
If nothing is done there will be a new revolt, now or in six months’ or a year’s time.
A year ago the government’s reaction was to declare a state of emergency in the areas concerned. Today its response is the same.
Seizing on a tragic incident where a bus was burned in Marseilles, leaving one passenger in a critical state, the government is stepping up repression.
Four thousand extra police have already been sent into the banlieues.
Now Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy, a front-runner for next year’s presidential election, is calling for a change in the law so that minors can be sent to prison.
Meanwhile the magistrate investigating the Marseilles incident is talking about sentences of 30 years for those responsible.

Police raid Mexican city protest camp

As the Voice went to press, violence continued in the embattled Mexican state of Oaxaca. Protests began in May this year when teachers began a strike, demanding better pay and a raft of measures to help poorer pupils.
The teachers are also calling for the resignation of the state’s governor, Ulises Ruiz, who is widely accused of corruption and orchestrating brutal crackdowns on demonstrators.
An umbrella group of protestors has coalesced around the teachers, and this weekend thousands of police officers raided their city centre campsite. At least one protestor is alleged to have been killed in the ensuing violence.
This followed the death of two protestors and an American filmmaker on Friday. The US Ambassador to Mexico has stated he believes it may have been Oaxaca police who shot the journalist.
Protestors have regrouped and intend to reclaim their camp.

—page twelve—

Free school meals bill grows organic support

“There is no doubt that the demand for free school meals is winning massive public support across Scotland,” says Frances Curran MSP.
Frances is piloting a Free School Meals Bill through parliament which aims to provide free healthy meals in all of Scotland’s primary schools with an enabling power for councils to extend them to secondaries.
The bill would take the campaign for healthy eating away from Scottish Executive hand wringing, says Frances, and would make a major contribution to the long term health of the Scottish population.
It is likely to face a hostile reception from New Labour and their supine LibDem junior partners who claim that, at £74million a year, it is too expensive. But last year alone the Executive under spent its own budget by £235million.
Campaigners have been out in force, publicising and building support for the bill, and getting a warm reception, despite cold conditions.
The SSP’s Edinburgh Central branch held a stall on free school meals at the Farmers’ Market on Saturday. 
“This was a new venue for us,” says branch member Barbara Scott. “We thought that customers of the market were already thinking about organic, locally produced healthy foods, so they were half way there! 
“We also decided to give away free fruit, which we were kindly given by a local food initiative. We attached credit card-sized leaflets to the fruit with email addresses for the free school meals campaign and the SSP. 
“Despite the inclement weather, the stall was a great success. The feedback was very positive, with lots of people saying they supported the bill. 
“We’ll definitely be repeating this exercise, and we hope next time to be able to ask people to fill in postcards to their MSPs asking them to support the bill when it’s debated in parliament.”
This Saturday in Glasgow campaigners will be putting the free school meals case to visitors to a major organic food event in the Old Fruit Market, Candleriggs.
Anyone wanting to help the campaign will be welcome at the venue from 11am.

Battle begins to save Inverclyde’s council housing

Campaigners determined to save Inverclyde’s council housing have welcomed the nearby Renfrewshire vote against housing stock transfer, and declared their resolve to build for the same result.
Local MSP Frances Curran said:
“The SSP wholeheartedly congratulates tenants in Renfrewshire for rejecting bribes, threats and lies by the proposed private landlord and Renfrewshire Council.
“Yet another group of tenants have decided that their best bet is with a publicly accountable landlord rather than the stooge outfit offered up.
“We are convinced that Inverclyde tenants will reject a move to private landlords.
“Tenants in Stirling, Edinburgh and now Renfrewshire have kicked it into touch.
“One of the few transfers to go ahead is Glasgow. The Glasgow Housing Association (GHA) is in absolute crisis and tenants in other areas have taken heed of this warning.
“GHA tenants are facing a bill of £500million to go to a second transfer. The Chief Executive Michael Lennon has been given a wage hike of 26 per cent on an already massive £200,000 salary. Who pays for all this? The tenants.”
Greenock resident Davy Landels added:
“The SSP are starting an intensive campaign of leafleting to get the ‘no’ vote out. This is not a done deal, despite what the council might try to tell tenants.
“We believe the best course of action is for Inverclyde tenants to follow their fellow tenants in Renfrewshire, Stirling and Edinburgh and demand public investment, not private landlords.”
The campaigners face a David and Goliath battle - other councils have poured millions of pounds into advertising stock transfer. But recent ballot results show tenants are quick to see through the gloss.

Free Leo!

Lev, an asylum seeker from Knightswood, Glasgow, and a good friend of the Voice team, narrowly avoided deportation last week.
Lev, who’s also known to many friends as Leo, was detained at Brand St last week, then transferred from Dungavel to Colnbrook high security detention centre, near Heathrow.
Hours before he was due to be put on a plane back to the country from which he fled, the deportation was halted. This small victory came after days of hard work by many people - we have to make special mention of Rosie Kane’s caseworker Donnie Nicolson, whose dedication and ingenuity was a driving force.
However, as the Voice goes to press, Lev remains in detention. He is currently held in the notorious Haslar detention centre - previously a prison, and all that’s changed is the sign outside.
Friends are very concerned for him - like so many refugees, Lev has Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. He’s been held in four different prisons in one week, and is feeling very insecure and frightened.
Lev’s NASS support was discontinued two years ago, and he’s survived in Scotland ever since then without a penny from the government, and without even bending a law - yet this vulnerable man finds himself jailed.
And there are thousands of refugees just like him - desperate, innocent and imprisoned - all over the UK.

WELCOMING COMMITTEE: refugees and supporters made sure Home Office minister with responsibility for immigration, Liam Byrne, got a taste of Scottish hospitality last week. The minister was in Scotland to discuss immigration policy, and announced to much fanfare that nothing is to change.
There were demonstrators gathered everywhere he went - the Scottish Parliament, Glasgow City Chambers, and then Brand St Immigration Centre in Govan.
Policing was heaviest at Brand St, where a woman was knocked to the ground by a police officer in the melee. One protestor was arrested after a plastic bottle was thr own.
However, over all, the protests remained positive, chants of “we belong to Glasgow” reminding Byrne that while refugees are welcome here, immigration ministers who oversee dawn raids, detention and deportations are not.