Scottish Socialist
Voice
Issue 321
29 th February 2008
front page
British Gas are ripping the profits out of us
WHAT
a difference a month makes in the world of British Gas.
On 18 January they announce that gas prices are set to rise by 15 per
cent for 9.7 million of their customers, and then on 21 February they
unveil they’ve made a massive profit of £571million
.
That translates as the energy giant making £1,086 in profit every
minute throughout 2007, with profit per customer increasing sixfold
from £5.93 to £36.
If ever there was an example of how companies like British Gas couldn’t
give a toss about their customers it’s this.
Who cares if a quarter of Scottish households are suffering from fuel
poverty, as long as the shareholders get a good dividend?
This won’t be the last price hike we see from British Gas.
They recently indicated that they’re considering introducing regional
pricing for gas - a ‘postcode lottery’ policy which will see consumers
paying different prices for gas based on where they live in the country.
If this occurs, other suppliers are likely to follow suit - some consumers
can expect to pay close to £100 more for their energy compared with
others living elsewhere in the country.
So if you live in a rural area, tough, pay-up.
The greed of these people knows no bounds, pensioners can freeze to
death, but it doesn’t matter because they don’t show up on their balance
sheet.
The Scottish Socialist Party stands for a
page two
Nationalisation
Rocks Labour’s
by Ken Ferguson
ELSEWHERE
in the Voice Raphie de
Baling out one badly mismanaged bank
has so far cost taxpayers an almost incomprehensible £110billion
with hardly a backward glance from our eagle eyed
MPs.
This from a government at war with civil servants on pay
and jobs, which makes pensioners live on a pittance, rations
life saving drugs to the sick and presides over ever growing
housing lists.
The left often says that government always finds money
for wars but even the billions wasted on the imperialist adventures
in
Not for the sharp suited punters in the casinos of the
City any lectures about restraint in public spending. So
central to the globalised financial world is the massive
So as ordinary people fork out for soaring food prices
and energy costs the gamblers are bought more chips paid
for with the taxes of the same ordinary people.
It is ironic indeed that our former Trotskyist Chancellor
and one time Red Paper writer in number 10 now find themselves
forced to exhume an apparently long dead socialist policy
in order to save the bacon of the city slickers.
The truth is that Northern Rock is just the tip of an ice
continent of debt resulting from the international financial chicanery
which has been heaped with praise by Brown, Blair and Darling
as the logo of our ‘modern’ enterprise economy.
As usual it will be the same ‘ordinary people’ who will
bear the cost of the moneylenders crisis with their homes jobs
and taxes and it is why breaking with the priorities of
socially unjust, planet trashing capitalism is ever
more urgent.
Perhaps since the Northern Rock was supposed to be about
housing it might be worth considering the fact that Shelter
This programme would cost a modest £750million which is,
set aside the Northern Rock bill, in the category of small
change.
More ineptitude on Northern Rock
NEW
Labour’s troubles with Northern Rock continue to grow.
It was revealed through questions in the House of
Parliament that an offshore trust, Granite, of Northern
Rock is not to be nationalised.
The trust holds, as security, £40billion of the highest grade
property of Northern Rock’s mortgage customers against
loans it raised in the financial markets.
This means that lowest grade in terms of credit risk
is offset against the tax payers’ money that the government
have pumped into save the bank.
This puts our money more at risk and will make it
more difficult to sell the bank back to the privates sector.
The government will have to pump into Granite several
billion pounds of more tax payers’ money as customers
move their mortgages elsewhere - something the new
government managers are encouraging in an attempt to
shrink the bank’s mortgage book.
In addition more than £5billion of Northern Rock money
(now our money) is held in the trust.
Boses step up union busting
by Ken Ferguson
AS
recession bites and profits come under pressure the
In a report by the British TUC bosses are accused of hiring
firms of union-busting consultants to persuade their
workers against the benefits of union membership.
And the TUC has joined forces with its
The TUC report is entitled US Union Avoidance Consultants:
A Threat to the Rights of British Workers, and has
been written for the TUC by John Logan from the
The report warns that the tactics used by union-busters
are designed to frighten and intimidate workers away
from any union attempt to recruit them at work.
This was the approach used recently to defeat demands for union
recognition at the supposedly upmarket crisp maker Kettle
Chips.
The approach, say unions is that highly paid anti union
consultants are hired by employers in the
Workers are also bombarded by bosses propaganda warning them that, if they join the
union, they are likely to be permanently on strike
and under threat of violence should they join any picket
line.
Trade unionists are bluntly warned that union-busting is
a multibillion-dollar business in the
TUC general secretary Brendan Barber said that the backstabbing tactics
employed in the shadowy world of the union-busting consultants
are proving increasingly attractive to a handful of
firms in
“Good employers realise the safety, communication and training benefits
of having a union at work and many actively encourage their staff
to join a union,” he said.
“But there is a small minority of bosses who fear the voice
a union would give their employees and will do almost
anything to keep the union out.”
“This is a
Report author John Logan added that, for over three decades,
socalled “union avoidance consultants” have helped
“It is essential that union-busting is not allowed to flourish
on this side of the
page three
The
Great
By Ken Ferguson
THE
divisions at the heart of New Labour’s response to the crisis engulfing
their former Scottish fiefdom, has forced a beleaguered Gordon
Brown to publicly back his Holyrood prodigy Wendy Alexander.
The ice age unionism which dominates Labour’s under employed
Westminster MPs has seen a growing campaign to derail Wendy’s
‘big idea’ of a unionist party commission to examine the powers
of the Holyrood parliament.
Traditionally Labour has been hostile to cross party campaigning and
Their concern is heightened by the debacle of the New Labour abstention
over the SNP budget and the positive concessions won by
the Tories.
This is what underlay the ill judged outburst from Scottish Office
minister and Inverclyde MP, the little known David Cairns, in
which he proclaimed that Holyrood’s powers were only an issue
for the “McChattering classes.”
There can be little doubt that
However his intervention posed a headache for his boss Brown
in that, faced with the current Cameron onslaught, Gordon
needs total loyalty from his MPs, but at the same time
needs to shore up an increasingly shaky Wendy.
Thus, setting aside the cares of the imperial capital - wars, bankrupt
banks, wealthy tax dodgers - the Fife MP turned his eyes
North and gave the BBC an interview.
As it was supposed to, the Prime Minister’s broadcast was largely seen
as putting the errant
However a closer look tells a different tale, with Brown firmly taking
a Union Jack stance, leaving little doubt that increased powers for
Favourite for return to
This carefully crafted message aims to sweet talk the London MPs,
while apparently supporting under fire Alexander.
Decoded it means - Wendy is a Brown loyalist, she is the best
we can get from that bunch in Holyrood but I’m the British
Prime Minister and
So, as the Voice has predicted before, expect moves to distance New
Labour from the increasingly confident Tories and power starved Lib
Dems.
A weakened Wendy has little prospect of winning any turf wars on
powers with Brown and he desperately needs to keep his MPs sweet
in the increasingly stormy political seas ahead.
In this situation the campaign to win an independence referendum takes
on added significance and this will be given added impetus with
a conference organised by the Independence First umbrella group.
The pro referendum Peoples Petition was launched by the Scottish
Details of the conference, which takes place at the STUC building in
Vote Scottish Socialist in Cambuslang
by Richie Venton
SCOTTISH
Socialist Party candidate David McClemont has been pounding
the streets of Cambuslang, challenging the other parties
with radical socialist policies that would transform the
lives of local people.
As polling day looms (6 March), David and the SSP team
are raising local and national issues that other parties fear
to touch.
As David says, “This is a chance for the people of Cambuslang
to shake up the council. To stop them taking us for granted,
neglecting our area and local services.
“Whilst other parties bang on about law and order, they say
nothing about the need for vastly improved facilities for young
people, to channel their energy and talents constructively.
As someone who has grown up and lived in the town all
my life, I know the council’s neglect of youth facilities often leads
to anti-social behaviour.
We need to invest in the town’s most precious future asset,
not demonise them.”
As the SNP government announces the monstrosity of the
£1billion M74 extension, the SSP has a unique track record
of opposition to this anti-people, anti-health, antienvironment plan.
We oppose it because it will stir up poisonous industrial waste
buried in the ground, and add to chronic levels of asthma
amongst all generations through increased air pollution.
We stand by the findings of the one and only independent inquiry
into the issue, which has been trampled on by both Labour
and the SNP in their eagerness to build more motorways.
This report showed the extension to be a costly disaster
that would fail to tackle congestion, would worsen the
existing climate change crisis, and do little or nothing to long-term
employment prospects in the area.
David says, “The people of Cambuslang need to resist this polluting
monstrosity - backed by Labour and SNP - and they can
start by voting for the proenvironment socialists on 6 March.”
Whilst the SSP has nothing against the reduction of dogfouling on
the pavements that other parties make central to the election,
we have also raised bigger problems and bigger solutions.
Uniquely, we have denounced the rampant profiteering by
multi-nationals in the cost of heating and eating.
Whilst local people struggle to cope with food bills, Tesco, Asda,
Sainsbury and Morrisons pile up obscene profits.
Families, pensioners, lowpaid and even middle-income families
find the cost of heating their homes an unmanageable nightmare
already. But now they face bills of over £1,000 a year,
as Scottish Power, Scottish Gas and others hike the price
of gas and electricity by 17 per cent - to feed their insatiable
hunger for profits.
Scottish Power, Scottish Gas and Shell made £500m, £700m and
£14billion in profits respectively in 2007. Shell’s greedy pile
alone equates to £2,500 for every man, woman and child in
David McClemont is training as a Social Care worker and works
part-time in a local nursery and elderly persons’ home.
“I know first-hand about the council’s failure to invest in
the services needed for all generations. For example,
in the newly built local housing, they are ignoring approaches
made about building nurseries.
And the SSP is also the only part that has fought for the past 10
years for free school meals for every child in
Local resident David Stevenson has written to the Rutherglen
Reformer advocating a vote for the Scottish Socialist
Party. In his published letter he writes:
“In the first 8 years of the Scottish parliament, the only party
to seek to scrap the council tax and introduce a progressive
tax has been the Scottish Socialist Party. The SNP paid
lip service to scrapping the council tax during those
8 years yet refused to support the SSP’s proposal, giving the
excuse that it was not set locally. Yet at last year’s elections
they hypocritically proposed a regressive centrally set
flat-rate tax.
The central difference between the SSP and SNP schemes
were that the SSP sought to shift the burden away from
the majority and not the wealthy minority, while the SNP
seek to insulate the wealthiest in society.
Voters have the opportunity to support a socialist solution
to the problems that beset our society and send a message
to all the parties that see pandering to the rich as their
fundamental duty that they want real change to benefit
the majority - rather than weasel words from Labour or
tinkering at the margins by the SNP.”
That’s the real choice - and SSP members should help spread
our socialist message in the days that remain in the Cambuslang
East by-election.
[1]
If you can help out, ring Richie on 07828 278 093
page four
Eco-Destruction To Take Away
Re-cycle your plastic bags to save the planet
IT’S
been nearly a year since Modbury, a small, picture-postcard
town in South Devon, became the
Last spring, all the town’s traders ceased issuing plastic carriers
and instead provided reusable or biodegradable bags. As the
local economy comprises only one small supermarket and forty
or so independent shops, the issue of corporate plastic bag abuse
did not arise, of which a little more later.
The town’s transformation began when Rebecca Hosking, a wildlife filmmaker
for the BBC, returned to her home town after filming a documentary on
a remote Hawaiian island, with a mission to wipe the plastic
carrier bag from the face of at least this one corner of
What fired her zeal were the hundreds of dead albatrosses
she had encountered during her idyllic-sounding mission in the
Pacific.
These tragic birds had choked to death on the everyday detritus
we throw to the winds, and seas, without a second thought:
cigarette lighters, bottle tops, toys...and plastic carrier bags.
Seals, turtles and dolphins were also found washed up and
choked up.
But the carnage doesn’t end there. When these creatures die,
their bodies decompose but the plastic that killed them does
not.
Which means it is released back into the environment to kill
again.
Hosking’s subsequent film, Message In The Waves, persuaded
Modbury’s shopkeepers to sign up to her plastic bag-free campaign and,
within a month, the rustling carrier was suddenly nowhere
to be seen.
Alternatives were provided. The butcher laid on corn and potato
starch bags, while the baker went for paper.
But alternatives are not the answer - the key message is ‘re-use’.
These days, locals rarely venture out without a trusty cloth
or string bag in which to bring home their purchases.
Indeed, there is a new civic pride afoot. One year on, and
locals can be seen stooping to pick up litter, and there has been
a renewed interest in local shopping, as opposed to the one-stop,
inyer- car, out-of-town supermarket variety.
Inspired by this example, places as diverse as Harrogate,
in Yorkshire, Kinross-shire in
But a scheme that works in small towns with a still surviving
local economy may struggle in a place like, for instance,
Supermarkets and chainstores are very, very unlikely to embrace
such a scheme as Modbury’s.
Plastic bags emblazoned with their logo is just too much free
advertising to give up for the sake of the soppy old environment,
and thus they will insist that it is consumers who demand plastic
bags and consumers who resist change.
Thus, Sainsbury’s dishes out 1.7billion bags and year, with
Asda squeaking ahead at 2billion. In all, we use some 10billion
plastic bags a year - and that’s just counting the ones we
get from supermarkets. We use each one for an average of 12
minutes before tossing it away, creating an annual plastic
bag dump of 100,000 tons.
Maybe we’d be less glib if we knew that all this pointless
plastic bagging costs the average
Or that our oceans are filling up with plastic trash at such
a rate that, already, we are practically eating our own plastic
refuse.
Research conducted by the Algalita Marine Research Foundation found
that plankton, eaten by fish, share their surface waters with minute
plastic particles, created by those millions of tons of dumped
plastic detritus we were just talking about. Plastic doesn’t biodegrade
as such, it ‘photodegrades’, which means it breaks up into
tinier and tinier pieces but never actually goes away.
A sample trawl of the North Pacific Gyre, conducted by the
SEA lab of
Our seas are literally filling up with trash; plastic in marine
environments is increasing at a rate of 100 per cent every
three years.
Animals don’t just choke on the big stuff, they are dying
from malnutrition through ingesting rubbish in the belief
that it’s food. Then there are the poisons, the Persistent
Organic Pollutants (POPs), such as DDT and mercury and lead,
that attach to the small stuff, the plastic particles that
act like sponges when it comes to toxins.
They end up in animals that we eat; therefore, they end up in
us, no doubt about it.
The big problem in relating all this stuff to a mass audience
in the
If we were slum-dwellers in
Furthermore, says Satish Kumar, editor of Resurgence Magazine,
we have a false idea that “everything on earth is lifeless
matter that can be used for human beings” and that our environmental crimes
are somehow victimless ones.
It isn’t so, and we need to get wise. The countries that have
issued an outright ban on plastic bags include, no, not
Meanwhile, in our nation of shopkeepers, the carrier bags
keep on coming, and the problems mount up, for lifetimes to
come.
page five
LETTERS
Between
Northern Rock and a financial crisis
Stands Our Money – all £100billion of it
by Raphie de Santos
THE
nationalisation of Northern Rock is the latest evidence of the breakdown
of global finance and the rule of the market.
The nationalisation has come about not to save jobs but to the prop
up the global finance system of which
Roots of the Crisis
As
short-term global interest rates fell on the back of the US Federal
Reserve (Fed) cutting
Under normal market conditions the rate at which you borrow money
becomes higher the longer the length of time of the loan. This is
to compensate lenders for the greater chance that a borrower may
default and fail to pay the loan back in full the longer the duration
of the loan.
But the Fed drove short-term rates down so low that the spread
between shortterm rates and longer term rates was very large
in most western economies. Financial transactions were designed
in all sectors of global finance to take advantage of this spread.
We have documented these in our previous article Money Market
Madness.
Northern Rock’s management came up with one of the riskiest and
ill thought through strategies as we will show.
The Bet That Blew Up
The
old model of mortgage lending was that a financial institution
tried to attract funds from depositors and pay them a rate of
interest below those the financial market rate. These deposits
are for medium and long term periods. They then could take this
money which was deposited with them and lend it out for long periods
in the form of mortgages at an interest rate above those available
in the financial markets.
Making a nice fat profit on the spread between where they borrow
from depositors and where they lend to mortgage borrowers.
As long as they could keep despoilers (lenders) with them or replace
them with others they could carry on making money.
Northern Rock’s strategy was based on a new model. They borrowed
short-term money from the
But two things happened in the Spring/Summer of 2007 which stopped
Northern Rock doing this.
One, the
Two, the sub-prime mortgage crisis broke in August 2007 and the money
markets dried up as the banks stopped lending to each other and
to smaller banks like Northern Rock because nobody knew for certain
who was credit worthy anymore or who could go bankrupt.
As Northern Rock’s short-term loans matured they could not replace
them with fresh loans at rates that were still profitable or the major
banks would not lend to them because of doubts about its ability
to pay the loan back.
On the Brink Collapse
At
this point if the banks that had leant money to Northern Rock had called
in their loans to them Northern Rock would not have been able
to repay them as the money had been lent out to home buyers.
Defaults by Northern Rock would have had a domino effect causing
a whole series of defaults and bankruptcies in the financial markets.
This is when the
The government has so far given up to £110billion to pay off Northern Rock’s
loans. £110billion of our money.
Hub of Global Finance
Western governments basically said to the
Why Did It Happen?
Undoubtedly
the Northern Rock management bear some of the responsibility
for coming up with strategy in the first place and not thinking
through the consequences of the strategy and factors which could
change which would make the strategy impossible to be continued.
But the major blame for the crisis lies with the New Labour government.
They created a financial regulatory framework that was totally
inadequate for policing global finance in the
It was their job to protect ordinary people’s involvement with
financial products and police the financial institutions. The FSA is
packed with accountants and administrators and lacks the knowledge
of the workings of financial markets and the products that are
created by these markets.
They were unable to spot the flaws in Northern Rock operating model.
The hedge funds and investment banks had and had been selling
Northern Rock’s shares since the start of 2007 expecting some
sort of collapse of its business because of it flawed operating
model.
The
How are the government looking at the workings of the FSA? They have
asked the FSA to carry out its own internal investigation as
to what went wrong!
There needs to be an independent enquiry with independent experts
from the financial markets taking part in it.
Believe it or not there are plenty of people in the financial markets
with a social conscience and even some socialists.
Who Are The Losers?
The
They need to reduce the size of the loan book to reduce how much
money they have loaned to Northern Rock.
They will do this by offering unattractive rates to borrow money from
them for homeowners. This will be done to discourage new borrowers and
make existing borrowers move their mortgages to another bank.
This will mean staff redundancies with up to 3,000 to go immediately.
Then more to go over time as the business is slowly run
down.
The individual share holders will loose out. The bank is
worth nothing and shareholders will receive a few pence
to zero for each share they hold. The individual share holders
are a mixture of staff who received shares as part of Northern
Rock’s demutualization. These shares are effectively deferred
wages.
The second set of shareholders is individuals who had accounts with Northern
Rock when it was a mutual organisation. Again these are ordinary people
from the North East of
The third group to lose out are those people whose pensions and insurance policies
where invested in Northern Rock through fund management and insurance
companies. Again this group are ordinary working people.
The only group of Northern Rock shareholders that socialists should
have no sympathy with are the hedge funds.
Two SRM Global and RAB Capital, bought between them about 20% of Northern
Rock expecting the shares to recover after the
Anyway plenty of hedge funds made money out of the collapse of Northern Rock’s
share price.
The Future?
Initially,
Darling was claiming that nationalisation was a short-term solution
but already Ron Sandler, the new chairman of Northern Rock, is saying
that the bank could remain nationalised for years. Highlighting Darlings
complete lack of understanding of the situation. No-one is going
to buy a mortgage business in the current environment of increasing defaults
and a tightening credit market unless they have offered a nice sweeter or
discount. Darling found this out to the further tax payers’ expense
to the tune of £100million - the fees to the city for receiving
advice on Northern Rock’s sell off.
A socialist government could have nationalised Northern Rock, compensating
the small shareholders and turning the bank into a social bank offering
low cost loans to those in real need or who were struggling with existing
loans to commercial banks.
Northern Rock crisis is part of a much larger crisis in the global financial
system. The problem for the financial markets and ordinary people is
that nobody knows where the next rupture in the system will be. There
is 23 trillion US dollars of credit insurance guaranteed by
global banks - most of whom have exposure to the sub-prime loan
market as well. That’s three times the gross domestic product of
the
Global finance has clearly failed not just the poor of the developed
world but working people in the western world. The time has
come for it to be replaced with a rational system based on meeting
people’s needs and ending poverty.
[1] Raphie de Santos is the former head of equity derivative research and strategy at Goldman Sachs International and now works as an analyst in the fund management industry.
centre pages
Democracy Cuban Style
In
a week that saw Cuban President Fidel Castro announce his retirement,
Thomas Swann looks at the current elections taking place on
the
AT a conference on democracy in
In response to Václav Havel, Arpád Goncz and Lech Walesa’s
comments, Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez said that ‘what
you have in
Similarly, political scientists have taken sides on the
issue with opinions of the democratic system ranging from
descriptions of a dictatorship in which elections are a
sham, to a proper democracy characterised by its reliance on
popular participation.
What is clear in the midst of this debate is that in
The democratic process in
This is the highest governing body in the country and is
headed by the president and is composed of ministers elected
by the National Assembly of People’s Power.
While it is probably unfair to compare the Cuban system
with the British form of liberal democracy, the Council
of State could be seen as somewhat similar to the cabinet,
with the difference that its members are elected as opposed
to appointed.
The National Assembly occupies a similar position as the
parliament does in
The best place to begin in attempting to get a grasp of
the distinctions and the workings of Cuban democracy is
at the bottom.
On the 1st of September last year, the first stage of the
process began, Asamblea de Rendicion de cuantas para elegin
al delegado, the nominations of candidates for the Municipal Assembly.
This activity is organised on a local community level,
with districts of no more than a few streets putting forward
individuals who will stand in an election for the local administrative
bodies.
Meetings of between 30 and 100 citizens vote openly on
who among them they consider best able to represent their
interests in the Municipal Assemblies.
As Maria Esther Reus, Minister of Justice and President
of the National Electoral Commission, explained in Granma
International, the weekly foreign language paper, “Those
nomination meetings are a key moment in the island’s electoral
process. Because, it is just in this period when active
participations in general elections is made material, in
addition to ensuring a broad scenario for the political
exercise of the population.”
When I visited
At 8:00 in the evening, people started to congregate around
the one house in the street which had working lights; there
had been a power cut since the early afternoon.
After an introductory speech was heard and the national
anthem played the nominations began. By this point the
power even to this one house had failed and the street
was lit with a car’s headlamps. About fifty people were assembled.
The process was brief but effective with two citizens being
nominated. Members of the assembled community simply shouted
out the names of those they wanted to nominate. The named
individuals then stepped forward before the small crowd.
A vote of hands ratified the selection and the paperwork
was completed, finalising the process. One of the nominated
candidates, Raul Estevez Garcia, was interviewed by two
Italian journalists.
He thought he had been nominated because of the effort
he had put into channelling the local community’s needs
and complaints during the most recent hurricane strike
on the island.
He seemed almost embarrassed to have been selected as a
candidate for election, an honour individuals cannot refuse.
“More than 50,600 assemblies will take place.”
A general election by secret ballot then decides who from
among those nominated by the local assemblies take seats
in the 315 Municipal Assemblies.
There are around 15000 delegates elected into these positions.
These assemblies then select from amongst their ranks candidates
for both the Provincial Assemblies and the National Assembly
of People’s Power.
In the second of these, the National Assembly, there are
614 seats to be taken up by members selected through the
process described above as well as from other blocs which
include representatives of the Federation of University Students,
the Women’s organisation, and the Cuban Trade Union Congress.
A slate of candidates for the National Assembly is drawn
up which registers the nominations made by the Municipal
Assemblies and the various other groups involved.
This slate contains one nomination for every seat and so
it is not the case that voters are asked to choose between
competing candidates as they are at the municipal level.
Rather, they are asked to ratify the recommendations of
elected representatives. In this sense, it would be better
to describe this stage of the process as a referendum given
that the electorate votes to either accept or reject the
slate presented.
Voters can either decide on candidates individually or
opt for a ‘united vote’ where the whole slate is judged
as a whole.
This stage of the democratic process took place on the
20 January.
Granma International reported that “8,231,365 Cubans cast
their ballots, the equivalent of 96.89 per cent of registered
eligible voters. 7,839,358 ballots cast (95.24 per cent)
were valid, and 7,125,752 of these (91 per cent) responded
to the appeal for a “united vote” for all candidates nominated
for the National Assembly. Blank ballots cast totalled
3.73 per cent (306,791) and spoiled ballots, 1.04 per cent
(85,216).”
The final stage, where the National Assembly elects the
Council of State is due to take place in a number of days.
This will determine
Despite this process, which begins at the local level and
culminates at the national, and is characterised throughout
by participation and independence from state authority,
critics will no doubt continue to denounce
However, as the above should have made clear, this is a
claim that makes little sense in the democratic system
that exists there.
The Communist Party of Cuba plays no role in selecting
candidates, and given that members of the various institutions
of People’s Power advertise no party affiliations, talk
of political parties does not appear to be coherent in
the Cuban context.
Brian Pollitt has commented that during the 1990s and beyond,
“despite great hardships and considerable social tensions,
the regime was evidently still sustained by a sufficient
body of popular support.”
This was and is because of the direct participation that
is offered to Cubans in the decision making process of
their country.
Voices
from
IN
the current electoral process in
The elections in January resulted in an average age of
elected deputies falling to 49 and more than 56 per cent
of the National Assembly being born after the beginning
of the Revolution in 1959.
During my recent visit, I took the opportunity to speak
to a number of young people about their political involvement
and their opinions of the system in
At a formal level, the Cuban youth is represented through
both the relevant wing of the Communist Party, the Young Communist
League (YCL), and the Federation of University Students
(FEU). FEU representatives are selected from classroom or
‘brigade’ level and councils exists at university level
and higher, all the way up to the National Assembly.
The president of the FEU at the Universidad Hermanos Saiz,
described the role the group plays in the university:
“The FEU is part of the directorate of the university.
To be able to enjoy our studies, we must be able to follow
the administration of the university.
“There can’t be arguments between the staff and the students.
To avoid this, the representative of each brigade is a
member of the directorate and so has a say in the structure
of the university.”
The FEU celebrates its 85th anniversary this December after
being founded in the 1920s by Julio Antonio Mella, also
a founder of the Communist Party of
A representative of the FEU from the Universidad de la
Habana (
“The youth should be able to think for themselves without
the interference of external systems.
“Our only commitments are to Julio Antonio Mella, to the
Revolution, and to
Rafael Gómez Castillo, a 3rd year computing sciences student
at the
“Despite this being true of many students, and the existence
of the FEU and many organisations like it, the general
feeling amongst those of university age in
Another student in
“Young people believe in the Revolution but there are some
things that are not right.
“The transport and the prices in the supermarket. Cubans’
minds have changed in the last fifteen years. We have seen
so many things.
“Young people, not all, but most, what they want is to
go out with their friends and to have fun.
“They don’t want to get involved because it means more
responsibility.”
Opinions on the causes of this apathy seem to be divided
however.
The student quoted above blamed it on the poor performance
of the bureaucratic civil service, plagued by corruption
in recent years:
“There are liars. Not in the government but between the
people and the government.”
Another student, from the town of
“A lot of people blame Fidel for our problems but I don’t.
I blame the American blockade.
“
Whatever the features of Cuban society that have led to
such disengagement from politics are, it is clear from
The avenues for participation remain open to young people
as they do for all sectors of society. Indeed, the change
that may result from the democratic system has been a topic of
discussion throughout the country. On 19 February, Fidel
(always referred to by his first name in
His age and recent illness means someone younger being
elected to the position he has held since the mid 1970s.
In a letter printed in the Cuban edition of Granma, Fidel
wrote, “it would betray my conscience to take up a responsibility
that requires mobility and total devotion, that I am not
in a physical condition to offer”.
“Fidel is a good man and has good intentions. He’s very,
very intelligent. I think nothing will happen when he dies.
He’s not been President for thirteen months.” said the philosophy
student from
As for Fidel’s brother, currently acting President (a role
prescribed for the Vice- President by the Cuban constitution
in the event of the President being unable to fulfill his duties),
“we don’t know much about Raul. He was head of the army.
That is all we know”.
Some commentators have suggested Foreign Minister Felipe
Perez Roque as a likely candidate for the presidency, with
others tipping current acting Vice-President Carlos Large.
It would be inappropriate, however, for outsiders to make
such predictions.
Ultimately, we will have to wait until Sunday to discover
who the National Assembly has selected to lead the country
for the next session.
Echeuarria, the FEU representative from
page eight
page nine
Starry Starry Morning
By John Haylett
WOULDN’T
it be great if Scottish socialists could keep up on news
about trade unionism, peace, justice, equality, anti-imperialism
and the environment in between their fortnightly reading
of Scottish Socialist Voice?
Well, the good news is that, from 3 March, you will be
able to.
On that day, the Morning Star will once again be in the
shops on the day of publication rather than on the day after
or even later than that.
Many Voice readers will remember the days up to six years
ago when that was the case and may wonder what happened
to the daily voice of the left.
Quite simply, our paper was done in by the big business
orientation of Royal Mail, which decided to axe an arrangement
which allowed newspapers that were part of the Minor
Titles Consortium to be carried on mail flights from English
airports to
The late-night flights enabled the titles to link up with
Scottish wholesalers’ distribution systems and to
be delivered along with the other papers to newspaper shops.
The Royal Mail decision didn’t affect only the Morning
Star. It affected ethnic minority papers such as the
Daily Jang and the Dziennik Polski and a number of specialist
and overseas titles.
Since then, there have been numerous attempts, including
by MSPs and Scottish
The Morning Star was left with a choice of simply whinging
about the Royal Mail board or of doing something about
it.
We chose the latter, investing in new arrangements to take
papers from our printers in Essex to a distribution depot
in
It sounds simple, but it’s also very expensive, costing
over £50,000 a year in additional distribution costs, which is
no small sum for a modest enterprise such as the Morning
Star.
But we felt that our Scottish readers, hundreds of whom
have continued to buy the Morning Star in spite of its late
arrival, have been disenfranchised for too long.
We reckoned also that the generally more progressive political
outlook in
And we’re hoping that Voice readers will make up a fair
section of that increase.
So what will Scottish socialists get from reading the Morning
Star on a daily basis?
Well, for a start, the Morning Star masthead proclaims
our creed as For peace and socialism, which distinguishes
our paper from the rest of a daily media that regards capitalism
and war as the normal way of things.
It reports stories that never see the light of day in the
big business press, penetrating the blanket of disinformation
about countries such as
The Morning Star has consistently supported CND and other
peace movements, opposing the invasions of
But it is not simply in the sphere of news reporting that
the Morning Star excels.
Its features pages include regular columns headed Voices
of Scotland, which include major articles by SSP members
such as John McAllion and Ken Ferguson, as well as Bill
Kidd MSP of the SNP, STUC general secretary Grahame
Smith, Labour MSP Elaine Smith, Vince Mills of the Labour
Party Campaign for Socialism, John Foster of the Communist
Party of
There are also provocative and informative articles by
the likes of John Pilger, Greg Palast, Ken Livingstone,
Derek Wall, George Galloway, Jeremy Corbyn and John McDonnell.
Scottish Trade Union Review editor Malcolm Burns has agreed
to write a weekly analysis of news in
The picture that ought to be taking shape in your mind
is of a Morning Star that is non-sectarian, a newspaper that
has set itself the goal of opening its pages to all sections
of the left and which intends to offer a service to all working
people.
Most left-wing parties have their own weekly, fortnightly
or monthly publications and it’s fair that they concentrate
on the activities of their party, but I believe that expanding
the readership and influence of the Morning Star can
contribute to a growing, more confident and, hopefully,
more united left as a whole.
In this, the lively letters page in our paper also plays
a role.
If there is activity in your area that you would like the
Morning Star to cover, call our news desk on 020 8525 6983.
And, above all, take the coupon on this page to your local
newsagent and order your daily Morning Star from 3 March.
The
Wild Brunch
Keef Tomkinson
Keef casts his eye across life’s more leisurely pursuits in order to put a wee bit of CULTure into our lives.
The Quest For Truth
I
have a shit job. I sit at a desk and do things with spreadsheets,
emails and software packages so that some ungrateful prick
of a financial advisor can grunt a begrudged thank you.
I like to call it a
If you watch that you will know that he had a similar number
crunching position which nobody could describe or remember.
No matter how many times I tell folk that I do not work
in a call centre, somebody making conversation always asks,
“You still in the call centre?”
So when I get home I want to be entertained or educated
by whatever media form I am interacting with. There are
some things I don’t wanna hear about. And presently at
the top of the list is the inquest into Diana’s death.
I call her diana in lower case cause she was a filthy rich media
hungry attention seeking waste of air, whose caring was
about ego rather than some solution to end suffering. She
died in a car crash. Sadly, 1000’s of people die in car
related accidents and even more sadly their stories are
never heard.
But we have to hear the boring, the bizarre, the paranoid,
the pointless notions as to what happened the morning that
Parisian road released us from her. In fact it turns out
we’ve had £6million worth.
Well if we’re willing to waste taxes on that, here’s the top
five inquests
5) How much is too much irony? - Me and my friends like
a good drink. As part of that the irony and sarcasm levels
increase in lines with booze inhaled. After a few hours
our ironic piss takes of racists becomes so dense most
innocents would consider us KKK sponsors.
4) What is that smell in TK MAXX? - You know what I’m talking
about. I’ve been in stores across
3) Why Tennents? - Globalisation and the relaxing of economic
barriers have opened Scottish drinkers to a new world of
beer. San Miguel, Stella, Heineken, Budvar, Cobra. I’m
currently into Tiger beer. So why is that thousands of
us still willingly drink Tennents? It’s minging, but yet
I, and others, wander into pubs and order it. Is it the
price? National pride? Faulty taste buds that know no difference?
2) What’s with the Valentine’s double-talk? Last week hundreds
of couples agreed that Valentine’s is a scam that belittles
their love. Both sides agreed that they will express their
mutual adoration spontaneously and not at the bidding of
Hallmark. Yet hundreds of guys will have returned home
after work to an expectant face demanding that little surprise.
But you said!!!! Too late. Is it a global feminine conspiracy
to make men uneasy or evidence of man’s chemically based
inability to read the situation?
1) What is the one true religion? - Celtic or Rangers? Is there
a sectarianism the fans of catholicism and protestantism
linked to their beliefs in Celtic and Rangers? Should the
opinion of Rangers believers be valid? Is God a green ball
or an orange shin pad? What is Tommy Burns’ role in this?
page ten
By Sam Gordon
THE
Nicaraguan media recently had a forty eight hour field day.
The country’s Sandinista President Daniel Ortega appeared on Venezuelan TV
alongside that country’s President Hugo Chavez.
In itself that was enough to irk some of
Then Chavez suggested that countries of the Bolivarian Alternative for
the Americas (ALBA) should set up a joint defence strategy, integrating their
armed forces and intelligence services because they all faced the same
enemy - the US Empire. The blue torch paper had been lit.
Economic and cultural integration of the ALBA countries has been smouldering
away for some time.
But not every country in this continent shares Chavez’s vision
of a new socialism for the 21st century.
Political, economic and military life all feel the chill of nationalist rivalry.
The Nicaraguan press need not get too agitated about this particular
squib.
There are plenty of impediments to this type of integration. But
it is a sign of changed times that such notions make it to
the headlines.
Latin America is sharing its ideas and
experiences.
In 2003 President Lulu of
This piece of social policy is aimed at tackling the continuous
cycle of poverty that reproduces itself every generation.
Does that sound a bit like the Scottish experience?
At its core is the question of availability of food and targeting
the supply of food to the most vulnerable in
Last year
In
Ironically, this country is rich in fertile land but the rural
areas are home to many of the poorest.
The Zero Hunger programme has started to donate cows, pigs and chickens
to poor families in the countryside. Seeds are supplied for maize
and other staples. Biodigesters are also available. These help
produce fuel from organic waste.
Traditionally cooking fires use wood cut from trees so this fuel
supplement ought to have a positive impact on the environment.
But any sort of material donation has the capacity to damage an
already vulnerable imbalance.
With this in mind the programme provides technical assistance and training
in animal and crop care. A mother-infant health measure brings the
health ministry into play. It is estimated that 100 000 families
will benefit over the next five years with an initial cost
of US$ 50million.
A decision by the Inter-American Development Bank to cancel
The idea is that families become more self sufficient in putting
food on their plates with something over to sell and raise
some extra income.
This programme has not the same revolutionary ring to it as the
Agrarian Reform Programme of the Sandinista government during
the 1980s.
Then big, unproductive farms were taken from the land owners and distributed
to the rural landless who had worked there for generations.
Not all the political forces of the 80s are at play today but for
many the social conditions continue to be dire.
And Zero Hunger has its critics too; from the right, left and centre.
Climate change will certainly affect the final outcome as will
the use of fertile land to harvest crops to produce diesel
fuel.
Some say too much is being spent on administrations costs such
as salaries with no official information on compliance with
programme targets.
Others just get into a state when Hugo Chavez talks with any other
Latin American leader.
Another media field day is looming.
Musharaff defeated
By Voice Reporter
The result throws into doubt not only the future of the dictator
but also the entire role of
The result is the more stunning given the widespread belief
that there would be serious attempts to rig the election and
that major forces - including the Left - boycotted the poll.
Accepting defeat Pakistan Muslim League-Q leader Chaudhry
Shujaat Hussain said that “we accept the results with an open
heart” and “will sit on opposition benches” in the new parliament.
The message for Musharraf from former prime minister Nawaz
Sharif to the humiliated general was blunt . He should consider the verdict of the voters
and stand aside.
Several close political allies of General Musharraf were also
election casualties.
The chairman of the ruling party, the foreign minister and railways
minister were among those who lost seats in
Significantly religious parties also fared badly and are set to lose
their control of the
As the Voice went to press Musharaff was stubbornly clinging
to office but as the assassinated Beanzir Bhutto’s
by Kiraz Janicke
[1]
Article originally published the Australian Green Left Weekly,
Kiraz Janicke is a member of the GLW bureau in
“THIS
is pure judicial terrorism”, Venezuelan energy minister
Rafael Ramirez told reporters in
The injunctions froze more than US$12billion worth of
assets of the Venezuelan state-owned oil company
PDVSA in
ExxonMobil, parent company to Esso and Mobil, has also
frozen $300 million of PDVSA funds held in a
“If they think that with this they will get us to backtrack
on our nationalisation policies, well, gentleman
from ExxonMobil, you are dead wrong again”, Ramirez declared.
As part of a drive to recover full sovereignty over its
natural resources, the Venezuelan government of
socialist President Hugo Chavez nationalised ExxonMobil’s
41.7 per cent stake in the Cerro Negro project in the
Other major oil companies including US-based Chevron
Corp.,
As well as ExxonMobil, USbased company ConocoPhilips
also rejected the nationalisations, but has said
it is seeking an “amicable resolution” with
ExxonMobil, however, rejected an initial compensation
offer from
The injunctions were solicited by ExxonMobil in anticipation
of an arbitration ruling by the International Centre
for Settlement of Investment Disputes over a compensation
claim. The court cases are ongoing, and the next hearing
in
The Venezuelan parliament has passed a motion declaring
the injunctions illegitimate, claiming it violates
Venezuelan sovereignty using the argument that only Venezuelan
courts should decide on issues relating to Venezuelan resources.
Ramirez accused the
PDVSA is a crucial source of funds for the Venezuelan government’s
social programs that provide free education and health care
to the poor. In 2006, the company spent $13.3billion
on such programs, up from $6.9billion in 2005.
Ramirez said
During his weekly television show, Alo Presidente, on
11 February, Chavez argued that ExxonMobil’s actions
were part of a
“They will never rob us again, those bandits of ExxonMobil”, Chavez
said. He described the corporation as “imperialist bandits, white
collar criminals, corrupters of governments, over-throwers
of governments, who supported the invasion and bombing
of
Chavez threatened that unless the injunctions were dropped,
Chavez said: “If the economic war continues against
Nicaraguan President Daniel Ortega offered his support
to
On 12 February, PDVSA issued a statement explaining that
it was freezing all its business dealings with ExxonMobil
in retaliation against the injunctions. The previous
day, PDVSA instructed its traders to deposit oil receipts
with the UBS bank in
The actions by ExxonMobil have been roundly rejected
by the vast majority of Venezuelans, who rightly
see this as an attack on their national sovereignty and
right to control their own resources.
Protests have been occurring all around the country, including
by the oil workers at the nationalised Cerro Negro
plant (now renamed Petromonagas). On 14 February, thousands
of Venezuelans turned out in the rain at PDVSA headquarters
in
Many people spoke of the need to mobilise against US
aggression, to deepen the struggle for socialism,
and to defend the democratically-elected Chavez government.
Further demonstrations outside the
Journalist Mari Pili Hernandez, who spoke at the 14 February demonstration,
said the most significant thing was that for the first
time in ExxonMobil’s history - since its origins as Rockerfeller
owned Standard Oil in the 19th Century - an entire
country has stood up to the corporate giant.
There is a real sense of national pride in this defiance.
There has also been a sense of anger among poorer
sectors towards the reaction of the pro-capitalist opposition
- based on the elite that governed
The US-funded opposition have gloated over the freezing
of PDVSA’s assets and blamed the government for
its nationalisation policies - once again exposing them as
lackeys of
Luis Carvajal, a union leader at the Cerro Nero/Petromonagas
plant said: “This transnational has exploited our
wealth, our workers and violated our rights - all the workers
in the
Castro resigns after nearly 50 years in power
By Ken Ferguson
FIDEL
Castro, who has served almost fifty years in the
leadership of the Cuban revolution, has resigned following a
prolonged period of ill health.
Fidel led the revolutionary forces to victory against
the
Under his leadership
Indeed no less a figure than Nelson Mandela spotlighted the
central role of
Large parts of
Despite an unremitting hostility from successive
After the Soviet collapse well heeled lobbyists and capitalist politicians
predicted the imminent demise of the Cuban revolution.
Yet despite several tough years known as the “special period”
it endured.
Now
Far from teetering on the brink of collapse as predicted
Attempts to present Castro as a new Stalin - ironically by
leaders who have unleashed high tech war on
In his resignation letter Fidel, with typical modesty wrote:
“My wishes have always been to discharge my duties to
my last breath, it would be a betrayal to my conscience to
accept a responsibility requiring more mobility and dedication
than I am physically able to offer.”
The Cuban national assembly will meet to elect a new President
but the leadership of the country is currently in the
hands of his younger brother Raul.
It was noticeable that even the hostile hacks of Channel
4 and the BBC had to accept, as the news broke that
, to parody Mark Twain reports of the death of the
Cuban revolution has been greatly exaggerated.
page twelve
A woman’s struggle is never done
By Pam Currie
JESSIE
Stephen was a feminist, a socialist, a trade unionist and an activist
for over half a century, from her teens until she died in 1979.
Yet her name is all but forgotten, ‘hidden from history’ - buried
by an education system and a labour movement men’s accomplishments
and contributions are celebrated while women’s are all
too often forgotten. Unusually, though, Jessie wrote down
her achievements - she wrote an autobiography, never published
- and she was interviewed in April 1975 in the feminist
magazine, Spare Rib.
Born in
Jessie was not content with this life, and in her first job
used what her trade unionist father had taught her to
hold out for a wage 6/- a month above the ‘going rate’ for
her age. Jessie was just 16 years old when she began to organise
other maids in the Scottish Domestic Workers Federation,
despite having only one afternoon and evening per week
in which to write to and visit other workers. Letters from discontented
domestic workers began to appear in the pages of the
The Federation held a packed founding meeting in
The mee